Skip to main content
Participating Frequently
November 8, 2018
Answered

ENCORE ISSUE AGAIN

  • November 8, 2018
  • 4 replies
  • 422 views

This has been discussed many times before, yet I feel as though Adobe remains silent whilst so many have complained. I have not yet found a clear reason why Adobe dropped Encore for CC. The popular belief is that optical media is dying and as such, there is no reason for an authoring program. I don’t fully agree with that premise, but even if it were true, there is still a need for Encore.

I produce videos with Encore, create ISO files with them and put them on a PC for viewing. The Cyberlink player works, as en example, very well with authored Bluray or DVD ISO files

Even without optical media, viewing a longer video production with menus and chapters has it’s advantages.

Now, with plans to puchase a camera such as a GH5 and film in 4k, Adobe’s solutions for authoring are unrealistic to the point of being absurd.

And, if I have a 4k film, why should I have to downscale it to 1080P? In CS 6, one can only create films in DVD format or Bluray HD format. The 4096 x 2160 4k is not available.

This is unrealistic. The solution would be to either update CS6 Premier Pro and Encore so that they can handle full 4k resolution or add Endore to CC. It’s unrealistic for Adobe to charge the monthly price that they do and not have a fully compatible Encore in the mix.

There seems to be a good way of of doing business and a bad way of doing business in the digital world. As an example, I have a Samsung laser printer that I purchased in 2015. The lastest drivers are from 2017. They no longer work with Windows 10. Samsung sold their printer business to HP and HP have not written better drivers. As a result and after lots of work, I was able to make the printer work using the Microsoft PLC6 drivers. But, why do I have to be the person to make their product work better when they won't do it themselves?

Recently, I purchased a Canon 7250 printer, it's drivers are up to date even though that printer was made in 2012!

Which business plan is Adobe following?

Solve this issue.

This topic has been closed for replies.
Correct answer John T Smith

Read reply #15 for why Encore was ended https://forums.adobe.com/thread/2454744

4 replies

SES312Author
Participating Frequently
November 8, 2018

I prefer viewing video with the ability to use menus and chapters. Whether or not said viewing is done from an optical disc or from an ISO file on a PC is irrelevant. Yes, I had read that Adobe had lost the rights to Encore as it was. But, having an authoring program, in my view should still be part of Adobe'sservice.

Because one group of users has no need for an authoring program doesn't mean that everyone has no need for this tool.

kglad
Community Expert
Community Expert
November 8, 2018

see message 1.

John T Smith
Community Expert
John T SmithCommunity ExpertCorrect answer
Community Expert
November 8, 2018

Read reply #15 for why Encore was ended https://forums.adobe.com/thread/2454744

Abambo
Community Expert
Community Expert
November 8, 2018

ses312  wrote

I have not yet found a clear reason why Adobe dropped Encore for CC.

This is my knowledge on this: Encore (or core parts of it) has been licensed from a third party. That third party has been acquired by a third company and the license has not been renewed. If you need Encore functionality and Encore CS6 is no more producing the required data, you need to buy a different program. I have had no need for producing DVD or Blue Ray disks for now more than 10 years. Once a user requested a DVD, but after talking to him, he just needed to play a film on a TV screen during an exhibition. All modern TV sets have the possibility to play video from an USB stick or from the network or you connect a computer (Laptop or similar) to the screen.

If you distribute your video data. you use something like youtube or vimeo. I suppose that you can even distribute your video data via iTunes and other similar services.

ABAMBO | Hard- and Software Engineer | Photographer
kglad
Community Expert
Community Expert
November 8, 2018

these are user-to-user forums.  post your request here, Feature Request/Bug Report Form