Hello, bug or ? [color shift]

Forum|Forum|2 years ago
December 26, 2023
2 replies
405 views

Hi everyone, Im new to photoshop, and im faceing some trouble, I open my RAW file ( Nikon cam ) and in the Camera Raw Filter I edited my pic, till here all ok, but after cliking on done to open it back in photoshop and save it as JPG, i noticed colores shifted a bit and they r not as vibrent as they were in Raw filter, so i open the Camera raw filter again and i noticed the image there colores looks more vibrent, so what am i missing or doing worng? is it a bug ? * Left image after clsoing Camera Raw. Right image inside Camera Raw filter.

Windows

This topic has been closed for replies.

c.pfaffenbichler

Community Expert

Please set the Status Bar to »Document Profile« and post screenshots with the pertinent Panels (Toolbar, Layers, Options Bar, …) visible.

Are you editing the Raw images on Camera Raw or do you edit a developped image with the Camera Raw Filter?

FGAR82

Participant

Thanks for the help, will i import picture form my Z6 NEF file and open them on Photoshop, they auto open on camera RAW filter so I make few adjustment and click done and then it open inside photoshop and here the colors changes a bit than when i was on the Filter Raw mode. I dont know if i did what u asked for sorry if not.

FGARS2Author

Participant

says sRGB but up says RGB , not sure if u saw this !

D Fosse

Community Expert

Do you have a dual monitor setup, and is one of them wide gamut?

This difference corresponds very closely to the difference between sRGB and Adobe RGB / Display P3, which makes me suspect that ACR uses the wrong monitor profile.

Are you using a calibrator to make your monitor profiles? Which one?

FGAR82

Participant

No dual monitor setup, I have a samsung galaxy book pro 2 that has AMOLED screen and with profile of P3 changed it to Adobe RGB, but even if its P3 shouldnt both image look same ( unless on the RAW filter it ignores the P3 profile and when its open in photoshop it goes back to P3 ) dono if im making any sence out of this !

D Fosse

Community Expert

with profile of P3 changed it to Adobe RGB

By @FGAR82

The monitor profile is not something you "experiment" with. Only one is the correct one, and that's the one that describes your display's actual and current behavior. Whenever that behavior changes, the profile is invalidated and you need a new one.

Either way, if this is a P3-type (wide gamut) display, you must use a calibrator. There's no way around it. Generic manufacturer profiles are far too error-ridden and notoriously unreliable.

Also, if this is a dual graphics laptop (they all are nowadays), you need to disable the integrated GPU. This is a huge problem with laptops.

The underlying problem is a fundamental one: this isn't a one-way downstream flow like it traditionally was, and still is in simpler applications. Photoshop uses the GPU for actual data processing, and the result returned to Photoshop for further processing. In this equation, there can only be one GPU. You can't send data to one and get it back from the other. Dual GPUs will very quickly conflict.

Keep in mind that applications aren't written to run directly on hardware. They are written to standardized APIs (Application Programming Interfaces). You have to assume that whatever is on the other side of those APIs work as intended.

Sign up

To post, reply, or follow discussions, please sign in with your Adobe ID.

Sign in to Adobe Community

To post, reply, or follow discussions, please sign in with your Adobe ID.

Scanning file for viruses.

This file cannot be downloaded