Copy link to clipboard
Copied
Hello,
My post is to show that i think there is something wrong with the profiles created by Adobe for some camera (5DS / 5DSR / 5DMarkIV), and i will try to explain why here. It's a serious post, and not a whining post etc.
I do a lot of retouching for many camera , and i'm stuck with the raw for 5DS/5DSR/5DMarkIV and not with some others (5DMark II/5DMarkIII/6D for example). No problem with Nikon/Sony at the moment.
My problem is about tonal response curve included in the dcp profiles. The dcp profiles for 5DS / 5DSR / 5DMark IV are made with an "adobe98-look" tone curve. Resulting in crushed blacks, and to much contrast.
Just to prevent some answers : it's not a calibration problem. I'm fine with all RAW for many camera, except 5DS / 5DSR / 5DMark IV, and i tested on many computers, mac and windows. And with different calibrated monitors etc.
How to see the problem :
5DMarkIII :
When I open the raw in DPP (canon), the raw have a srgb look (srgb / srgb).
When I switch to adobe98 (srgb / adobe RGB), the tonal look is "crushed" in black and contrasty.
When I open this raw in Camera Raw with the "Camera Standard", the tonal look seems to be in srgb, like in DPP. It's fine so
6D :
When I open the raw in DPP (canon), the raw have a srgb look (srgb / srgb).
When I switch to adobe98 (srgb / adobe RGB), the tonal look is "crushed" in black and contrasty.
When I open this raw in Camera Raw with the "Camera Standard", the tonal look seems to be in srgb, like in DPP. It's fine so
5DS / 5DSR :
When I open the raw in DPP (canon), the raw have a srgb look (srgb / srgb).
When I switch to adobe98 (srgb / adobe RGB), the tonal look is "crushed" in black and contrasty.
When I open this raw in Camera Raw with the "Camera Standard", the tonal look seems to be in adobeRGB, NOT like in DPP. It's NOT fine so
5D Mark IV :
When I open the raw in DPP (canon), the raw have a srgb look (srgb / srgb).
When I switch to adobe98 (srgb / adobe RGB), the tonal look is "crushed" in black and contrasty.
When I open this raw in Camera Raw with the "Camera Standard", the tonal look seems to be in >> adobeRGB <<, NOT like in DPP. It's NOT fine so
To summarize :
For some canon camera, you have edited your dcp profile to match dpp very well (6D / 5D Mark II / 5D Mark III), but for 5DS / 5DSR / 5DMark IV, the match isn't fine, because it is matching an "adobe98" tonal curve, and not a "srgb" tonal curve.
Is it possible that Adobe, makes "srgb look" dcp profile and not "adobe98 look" dcp profile ?
Thanks.
Hi benjaminvingrief,
Have you tried updating to Camera Raw 9.9?
Camera Raw installer for Adobe Photoshop CC and CS6
Regards,
Sahil
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
Hi benjaminvingrief,
Have you tried updating to Camera Raw 9.9?
Camera Raw installer for Adobe Photoshop CC and CS6
Regards,
Sahil
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
Have done some test all the night :
Fresh Yosemite and Maverick install : same thing.
Fresh Sierra install : same thing.
As you can see on this picture, black are completely crushed.. And there is a lot of red in the blacks. On the finger : over saturated reds etc... Near the border of the hair, saturated reds etc.
My photoshop and OS are just clean installed.