How much money do you not have to not fully test your features?
Next year I'm requesting we move to a different software
Hi, we would like to know what problems you are having with Adobe XD.
Where to start?
The project I currently work with started out in Sketch. I imported it into XD, and thought "wow, this actually works!"
Then I noted that masking works totally different. Fair enough, I went through about 4-500 symbols and re-masked them. To my chagrin, I noted that as soon as you mask something, you can't do zip about the layer order. You have to unmask, change order, then mask again. OK, so let's do that then, I thought, and found out that as soon as you change any groupings that contain text, all the text overrides in all instances of the symbol/component is reset.
By now I'm really starting to wonder about the speed and efficiency of XD. Not only all the extra manual work because the app behaves like the village idiot. But with a sh*t-load of artboards on the same canvas, moving, resizing or manipulating stuff reminds me of pouring really cold maple syrup. Where is that supposed "design at the speed of thought" thingie? Finding anything in the component library turns out to be painful. Rather than a neat hierarchy mirroring the design context, it is like a scattershot, sorted by who knows which parameters. Re-sorting to your own liking is pretty damn tedious, and when it has reverted to chaos the next time you open the file you give up. Searching sounds good, but require you to change focus from where you are to a search field, hoping you named your master in a reasonable manner.
A million years later, with all the symbols I actually need to override under control. Now renamed to be easy to find without hierarchy. With states replacing other overrrides etcetera, etcetera, ad nauseam, I'm supposed to start collab with another designer. We push the document into the cloud, and the maple syrup is turned into a slowly melting glacier.
As soon as you open the document, it starts "saving" (exactly what is a mystery), and is unusable for up to half a minute. Then as soon as you do anything, there is a freeze while it does an interative save. Those saves BTW is not always reliable, and from time to time, regressions surface, where elements, component instances and even component masters goes back in time to an earlier iteration. Not only does the app freeze for my own saves, it does so when my collegue does something and it gets saved. The only thing smooth about the process, is watching the element you just tried to move in vain, suddenly start sliding slowly over the screen as the app unfreezes.
By now, I'm just about on the verge of trying to force the team leaders to go all Mac for the designers, allowing us to use Sketch Cloud in place of the CC-cloud that never seem to work anyways. The only reason to live through this pain, is to allow the project to be multi platform. I'm even eyeing Figma as an alternative, just to flee the monumental pain of spending half my days waiting for and repairing whatever XD f*cked up.
This app need the following, ASAP:
Oh man, I am so very very pleased that you posted that beautiful list. I've been pulling my hair out with XD. I've recently moved over to Windows and my god, can you believe it's even worse?! I reckon in a 2 hour session I restart XD 3 times, no exaggeration, which is really excellent for focus. 😐 It often freezes when I'm trying to open another file, and at that point nothing works except killing it from task manager.
Overriding components is also a pain in my a*s . I could cry sometimes when I make a change to a component and suddenly every instance reverts to the origional state (copy and all). Luckily that's not happening that much anymore, so something has changed. But yeah, also what you were referring to in point 7 (override dependability).
One thing that you left out, which I believe isn't fixed yet: scaling/resizing borders and corner radiuses. This brought me a lot of agony last year when I was working on the marketing site for a product, and I needed to resize my designs. I wasted many hours of my life, for no good reason. This is a feature in Illustrator so I'm suprised it wasn't included in XD from the get go.
Unfortunately I'm stuck with XD because I need to be able to work on a client's project which already exists in XD, plus they're Mac and I'm Windows.
Yep this exactly, I don't think this is the case for the mac version, only on Windows. Continues bugs, crashes, freezes, fonts won't load properly, random other issues, text bugs in inputs etc. etc. Please test your software on more Windows systems! I'm not paying for this..
I feel your pain. It feels Adobe XD isn't tested on Windows. Last updates just added boring features instead of fixing bugs.
I have came back to check XD and wow it got worse. Did these guys write it with no concept of a testing! In less than 48 hours it has crashed several times for different reasons.
I just wanted them to fix the typing problem XD has. Wanna change a text? better ALT+TAB to get out and get back into XD. Wanna change a property, like size or position? Same thing.
Wanna open the layer panel and components panel at the same time? Sorry, can't do that
Wanna update a link of a shared prototype? Only if you're the owner of the file