A strange query of queries bug in CF11?

[Guest]

Hi,

I have this strange query of queries result that could be a bug in CF11.  The result is fine in CF10.

Basically, I have 2 queries, qrA and qrB.  I do a join of the two in joinQr, after which I do a query of qrA.  Since I didn't alter qrA in any way, I would expect newQrA to give me the same result as qrA.  However it only gives me one row ("D").  Now, here's the strange thing:  If I start off qrA with the letters in ascending order ["A", "B", "C", "D"], then newQrA gives me the right result.

<cfset qrA = queryNew("")>
<cfset queryAddColumn( qrA, "size", "varchar", [ "D", "A", "B", "C" ] )>

<cfset qrB = queryNew("")>
<cfset queryAddColumn( qrB, "size", "varchar", [ "A" ] )>
<cfset queryAddColumn( qrB, "quantity", "integer", [ 0 ] )>


<cfquery name="joinQr" dbtype="query">
    select qrA.*, qrB.quantity
    from qrA, qrB
    where qrA.size = qrB.size
</cfquery>

<cfquery name="newQrA" dbtype="query">
    select *
    from qrA
</cfquery>


<cfdump var="#qrA#">
<cfdump var="#qrB#">
<cfdump var="#joinQr#">
<cfdump var="#newQrA#">

[duncancumming]

it'd help if you showed us what these queries look like, and possibly some sample data.

[Guest]

Sorry, I had trouble inserting the code earlier.  It's fixed now.

[BKBK]

For your interest, by coincidence, my first test was with

<cfset queryAddColumn( qrA, "size", "varchar", [ "A","B","C","D" ] )> 

It turns out that the order "A","B","C","D" works, whereas "D","A","B","C" fails. Quite funny, really.

[Guest]

Thanks for confirming that it's a bug.  I will file a bug report.  I don't know what changes they made under the hood to QoQ, but to me this is serious because I can no longer trust the result of QoQ.  I wouldn't have caught this if a user didn't point out a result that made no sense.

[Guest]

Bug#3783011 - Query of Queries giving the wrong result

[BKBK]

Thanks. In discovering this flaw, you have done the Coldfusion community a big favour.

I have added my vote to your bug report. It reads: "+My vote. Query of Queries is a cornerstone of Coldfusion. This issue is so serious as to raise questions about the reliability of the entire language.".

[BKBK]

I made an error when I first tested your code with array variable names instead. However, I have now been able to reproduce your result. It indeed looks like a bug.