I use PhotoLine with various tools. The latest betas of PhotoLine add scripting support (vbs and C# with DLL compilation) which expands the scope a LOT.
PhotoLine and your list:
1) probably most important feature for me is possibility to extend and customize editor with my own panels and scripts
Yes, latest betas support scripting via VBS and C# visual studio projects. DLLs can be compiled as well.
I hope the devs will add custom dialogs as well.
2) i'm using instancing alot (symbols)
While PhotoLine doesn't have symbols, it offers Virtual Layers instead. Pretty much the same thing. A virtual layer is an instance/clone of another layer, and it updates in real-time when the source is being edited. Very powerful concept, because even adjustment layers and filter layers can be instanced and recycled - unlike symbols, which are limited to (collections of) objects only.
3) non-destructive (when both operands remain editable) boolean path operations (crop, intersect and so on)
Nah, unfortunately booleans are destructive in PhotoLine. Most other things are non-destrutive, though.
4) non-destructive filters
Most filters are non-destructive by default. No need to convert to a smart object to apply a Gaussian blur effect, for example. Those effects that are destructive can be applied non-destructively by converting the target layer(s) to a so-called placeholder layer (which are PhotoLine's "smart objects".
Boon: classic Photoshop compatible filters are also non-destructively applied to placeholder, just like Photoshop. No other design app, outside of Photoshop, is capable of doing this.
5) possibility to do simple raster work without leaving vector editor (including tracing)
PhotoLine absolutely obliterates Fireworks here. Bitmap editing is comparable to Photoshop. The beauty of PL: each bitmap layer can have its own image mode, bit-depth (8, 16, 32) and pixel dimensions. So feel free to combine Lab, monochrome, RGB and CMYK layers in the same layer stack!
PhotoLine offers quite nice vector editing tools as well. And treats vector layers as real vectors, outputting at max resolution if required, unlike Fireworks. Turn pixel view on or off. Turn anti-aliasing on or off.
PhotoLine combines image editing and vector editing in one app. Oh, and it supports bitmap to vector tracing as well (just convert a bitmap layer to a vector layer). Vector or bitmap patterns are possible too (or combinations).
6) 9-slice resizing
No, sadly not (yet). I am hoping the devs will implement this. I miss this option myself.
7) sub pixel vector editing
Yes, with the choice of snapping vectors to the pixel grid or not, and the option on a per-layer basis to turn off anti-aliasing as well.
8) slices or artboards to export document regions
No, no slicing. I dislike the slicing method myself, and prefer layer/layer group based export options. PhotoLine is already able to export multiple selected layers as individual files, and the latest betas include a Photoshop Generator script with layer names deciding how each asset is exported.
PhotoLine does support pages just like Fireworks, though. Each page may have custom dimensions, and all pages can be saved separately in one go.
The newest betas are expanding this functionality a lot (spreads support, for example) so it is possible to have three or more "artboards" side by side. Also true threaded text boxes!
9) smart shapes like doughnut or star or gear
Yes, various objects with live parameters. To access the live parameters you do need to activate the correct shape tool again, though. A bit clunky, but it works.
10) i love procedural workflow like Houdini has (fireworks don't have it as well)
Yeah, a nodal workflow would be nice 😉 No, while PhotoLine's workflow is mostly non-destructive, a procedural workflow is only possible via scripting.
11) sprite sheet generation (fireworks don't have it)
I use TexturePacker. Nothing else comes close, so why bother with anything else? Export my layers to a folder, and activate TexturePacker. Add more layers and assets, and TexturePacker watches the changes in the folder, and updates the spritesheet. Includes automatic @2x and more multiple resolution packing. Brilliant little app.
12) css code generation
No, not (yet) available in PhotoLine. I plan to write my own script to do this for me now that PL has script support. All properties of a layer can be read, so... Isn't hard to do.
13) good svg export
Yes, definitely. Good import and export. Also a really nice live link with Inkscape if required.
14) animation with onionskin
PhotoLine has a simple timeline that is detached from the main canvas or can animate the layers (use groups to manage each animation part). No onionskinning.
I never animate in PhotoLine. Nor do I touch the animation in Photoshop or Fireworks, because those are far too basic for my taste. Instead, I use proper animation tools such as OpenToonz, Moho, Blender, ClipStudio, even Krita. Depends on the type of animation. For simple hovers and related stuff I will just use multiple layer groups, and export those.
Anyway, I really like working in PhotoLine. I am a game and web developer myself, and PL ticks most of the boxes for me. It works wonderfully well with other apps with its external app-link: just send layers to another app from within PL.
Your scripting examples would be easy to pull off in PhotoLine as well.
Get the trial here: www.pl32.com
A portable version is also available! The beta version with scripting is available in the forum.
8
Replies
... Pages in Fireworks work just fine for me 
AdChoices