Copy link to clipboard
Copied
I used to be able to hold down Command (Mac) or Control (Windows) and click on overlapping objects to select objects underneath. It is not working for me in Illustrator CC 2019. Has this changed in Illustrator CC 2019?
Illustrator is quite fussy when using this technique.
Looking into this further, it works best if you move the mouse a little between the first and second click. Also, you may need to release the mouse in order to see the bounding box displayed so that you can identify which object is actually selected.
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
I discovered that Control clicking to select an object underneath seems to work if I click only on the edge of the object, even though I do NOT have Object Selection by Path Only turned on in Preferences. Control click to select objects behind is turned ON in preferences.
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
I am encountering no such change in Illustrator CC 2019 (Mac).
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
I'm on Windows 2007. The Control click to select behind feature is very buggy. I reset preferences and it's still buggy and completely useless.
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
No such issue on Windows 11.
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
I found that I was able to select objects underneath if I Control clicked the number of times that corresponds to how far down the object is in the stacking order. I am not able to see the selection bounding box until I release the mouse.
This is different from the way it used to work, and is no longer a useful technique.
Does anyone know if I'm doing something wrong?
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
I uninstalled and reinstalled Illustrator. Still buggy and inconsistent with this feature.
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
Unfortunate. Sorry not to have a solution to offer.
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
I appreciate that at least you responded. I'm glad that it's working on Mac OS.
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
Adobe will soon release 23.0.1 to fix some of the bugs in release 23. However, I noticed that this particular issue is not fixed.
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
Illustrator is quite fussy when using this technique.
Looking into this further, it works best if you move the mouse a little between the first and second click. Also, you may need to release the mouse in order to see the bounding box displayed so that you can identify which object is actually selected.
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
Yeah it works like crap, never works right from the start. Always need to press CMD LBM a couple times before it really starts doing anything.
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
By fuzzy you probably mean its buggy. The feature is nice, but why is the movement needed and not documented?
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
Use the layers panel and select object you want to work on.
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
@jay fresno
Hello. FWIW—today is November 2nd, 2020. I am on the latest AiCC, v25.0—and the command to select and underlying (hidden) object does not work for me either.
I'm here 'cause I just found myself attempting to select an object (hidden) under another (visible) object, and none of the umpteen combinations of tools, keys, and/or commands I tried will work to only select the underlying (hidden) object.
Only option is to go on a hunt'n'search in the layers panel ... [insert eye-roll here] So anyway, that's that, and g'day.
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
This is unbelievable. Any other CAD, drawing or layout tool has the option to select or list underlying objects. Even Photoshop and InDesign does it. It feels like the Illustrator devs abandoned their projct a while ago.
I'm cleaning up some CAD drawing exports and things like these drive me crazy (there is no way to select that single anchor point behind that other path than browsing the layers list):
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
This is unbelievable. Any other CAD, drawing or layout tool has the option to select or list underlying objects. Even Photoshop and InDesign does it. It feels like the Illustrator devs abandoned their projct a while ago.
I'm cleaning up some CAD drawing exports and things like these drive me crazy (there is no way to select that single anchor point behind that other path than browsing the layers list):
By @DimitriB82C
How about drawing a selection rectanlge around it and then deselecting what you don't want selected?
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
I find using the lock command faster when doing this kind of work. Fuzing around with that shortcut which is a bit buggy. Locking it and unlocking is faster
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
Just hold CTRL/CMD and click an exposed part of the layer. Works great. No more clicking a ton of times. (Illustrator Beta 28.1 2)
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
That makes no sense to the question!
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
I am sadly not surprised that this issue is still present in 27.9. The "Command+click" option automatically switches the cursor to a direct selection. Why can't Adobe fix it to function like inDesign that keeps the regular selection tool while holding command? It shouldn't come as a surprise that the object we are trying to select underneath could be a group (especially outlined text), so trying to select it with the direct selection tool is impossible.
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
It doesn't switch to Direct selection. It only shows a hollow selection cursor with a little triangle.
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
Well i tried it again. The mouse cursor on OSX seems to freak out a bit. At a certain moment, i see an open white pointer with a smaller arrow pointing to the left.
But its behavior is erratic. Sometimes it wont show and because of multiple clicking, it happens a lot that you move the most top object
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
You have to slightly move the cursor for it to work.
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
I do see how moving the cursor slightly works to get it to select below, but the same issue I brought up in my previous comment remains: It will select the object you directly click on, disregarding any grouping that object may have had (hence I used the direct selection terminology). The group that I am trying to select is completely separate from the group in front of it.