I have been using the 2017 version of indesign for ages due to its reliability to index a large book (600 or so pages).
I just installed 2020 in the hope they had fixed the bug that seems to make the little blue wheel spin indefinitely in 2018 when trying to create the index, whereas in 2017 it can create an index in under 6 mins.
Has this ever been addressed to fix? I feel like as long as I am required to index a long book (or just about any book) I am stuck in 2017. Does anyone else have this problem at all? Are there any workarounds that I am unaware of? And what happened originally in 2018 to bugger it all up? Any information appreciated!
If 2017 works ok why change?
There really isn't enough info to help you further - OS, RAM, etc.
What have you tried to remedy the situation already?
Have you looked on InDesign User Voice for similar issues?
As with any piece of software, the updated versions supply new functionality that old versions do not.
Sometimes, it would be nice to be able to use the newer version without having other versions to have to fall back on.
I am on a windows 10 PC, 32Gig Ram and lots of HD space.
So far despite searching community forums, no remedies have been offered.
I've not had your experience. That's not to say that you're not, of course.
I can offer some things to check though, that may help narrow down the problem:
Please let us know answers to these questions, and we'll do our best to help you vector in on the causes — and hopefully solutions — for your issues.
We're here to help,
1. The 600 page book is an indesign book comprised of about 14 documents.
2. When I tried to generate any type of index, be it from 1 document or the whole book, I just got the spinny blue waiting wheel that never went away.
3. Occasionally I need to make a editing tweak or index page adjustment - that's about all I ever go back into it for.
4. It's exactly the same book content that I ran in the 2017 version - no changes except InDesign wanting to convert all the files to the latest version first.
I hope that helps?
Ok - here's the first thing I'd do.
Create a new book file - and reimport the files.
See if that clears it up.
If not - then create another new book file - and load half the documents.
Try create an index.
If it works ok
Create a new book file - and load the other half of documents.
Try create an index.
If you get a spinning wheel and delay in either - you know there's something in those that is causing an issue.
Keep dividing the documents by half until you narrow down a problem file.
If there is no spinning wheel in either half of the document files - then at least we will know it's not the files themselves, or the book file.
I will try that and get back to you.
So I tried a brand new book and added the documents back in a few at a time and it all seems to work.
It must have been converting the book file into the newer format?
Unfortunately this new 2020 version seems to take over twice the time to do the index as the other one (7 mins vs 16 mins), and seems to have a big freeze /think at the end of an index (for about 5 mins) before you can do anything with it. But at least it's working.
That's great to hear.
I'd still do the divide and conquer method to narrow down the problem file.
There's something causing the issue.
Try a test file - duplicate your project to a safe place or back up your original project.
Try half the files in a new book file and see if it's quick.
Then try the other half.
It's purely an exercise to find the problem file.
When I have a bit more time I will delve deeper - it's good to know it at least works now.
I will definitely try break it down further to find what is causing the delays.
Appreciate your time and help!