Stapel gehen verloren, wenn Fotos zu einer Sammlung hinzugefügt werden

[mattjaeg]

Hallo,

Ich versuche, Fotos (auch mit vielen Stapeln) aus "Alle Fotos" in eine Sammlung zu übertragen. Leider gehen dabei alle Stapel verloren, d.h. nicht die Fotos sondern die Verknüpfung. Bei 100k+ Fotos ist das ein riesiges Problem und ein Killer für meinen Workflow, da ich Sammlungen praktisch nicht mehr nutzen kann. Ich bitte um rasche Hilfe (Workaround oder Bugfix)

Viele Grüße,

Matthias

[JohanElzenga]

This is not a bug, it is as designed and as expected. Stacks are 'local', not 'global'. If you stack images in 'All Photographs', a folder, or a collection, then they will not automatically be stacked in another collection. You can stack images A and B in one collection, A and C in another collection, and have image A not in any stack in a third collection.

[AxelMatt]

There's a feature request since 12 years:  P: Stacking in folders and collections should be g... - Adobe Community - 12250295

I don't think Adobe will implement this feature any time soon. 😞

[mattjaeg]

Thank you for the quick reply and let me explain the problem that I have with staples being local:

I am using the Topaz Labs software for editing frequently. It creates a copy, that is stapled to the original after the editing process. I do not want to lose this connection of the two images no matter in which collection I place them. How do I accomplish this?

Greetings and thanks in advance,

Matthias

[AxelMatt]

... It creates a copy, that is stapled to the original after the editing process. I do not want to lose this connection of the two images no matter in which collection I place them. How do I accomplish this?

By @mattjaeg

At the moment you've done that manually after you moved the stack into another collection.

As @JohanElzenga wrote stacks are local and are only valid in the collection in which they were created

As I wrote there's a appropriate feature request since 12 years ago. but nothing happens since this time.