I've got a catalog wth 500 images that I have pulaced into a custom order/arrangement. Is there any way to save this particular ordering? I want, for example, to resort the view based on a few things, such as file type of Added order, then return to the ordering I've created. Would a Smart Collection save the order, for example? (I don't want to try it to find out ;-)) Thanks for any help.
The only way I've found the guarantee the order is kept is to rename the images using a sequence number at the end such as "my-photos-001.jpg"
wish there was a robust function for this myself.
Thanks much, but in this case, that's not really an option. We need Save Sort Order function. So simple.
Custom Order is "saved" when you create it, and it remains set that way until you change it again, and switching back and forth between the various sort orders will have no effect on the set custom order. But you need to be careful that you don't inadvertently (or forgetfully) drag a thumbnail into a different place in the grid while using one of the non-custom sorting orders, as that will reset the previously set Custom Order into the new order that you just created by dragging that one thumbnail into a different position.
Well I spent about four hours yesterday getting the catalog into the custom order so that my slideshow would run in the desired sequence. I had to jump into another catalog to retrieve some images and I changed the sort order in that catalog to Capture Time. When I returned to my slideshow catalog, it had reordered all the images into Capture Time and my custom, well-planned, precision, carefully conceived, desired order was gone. I don't see any way to switch back to the custom order, but if you know of one, please tell me. Much obliged in any event.
I repeat: the only way I've found to save a Custom order is to rename the files in a sequential pattern so that, as Jim warns: "But you need to be careful that you don't inadvertently (or forgetfully) drag a thumbnail into a different place in the grid while using one of the non-custom sorting orders, as that will reset the previously set Custom Order into the new order that you just created by dragging that one thumbnail into a different position."
This is a long standing fail in LRC and hopefully, one of these days, will be addressed. Until then, rename away, it's the only way.
I get it. But as mentioned, renaming all the files is not an option at this point. And Jim mentions that the custom order can be accessed and moved away from, but that failed on my system.
How are you trying to use it? You mentioned switching between "catalogs" earlier, though I guess that's not what you meant. You can set a Custom Order for a collection or any sub-folder, which are you using? You can switch between the various sort orders (including Custom Order) when in the Library module by using the Sort drop-down list on the Toolbar, and whichever order you select there will be how the images are ordered in the Slideshow module. You can set or change a Custom Order the Slideshow module, but you can't switch the order from say Capture Time to Custom Order, you'd have to switch back to Library and change the sort order there.
Renaming is an option if you feel prone to inadvertently messing up the Custom Order, but I've never found the need to do that. YMMV.
Yes - thanks. I think that will do it.
The key is to pay attention to both the current source — which can be a single folder or single collection — and the current sort setting. Each source (folder or collection) does save its own Custom Order and as Jim said, as long as you have not changed that, it actually is saved.
I don't see any way to switch back to the custom order, but if you know of one, please tell me. Much obliged in any event.
In the Library module, a menu in the toolbar tells you which sort order is active, and one of the choices is Custom Order. That is where your custom order is saved. If you found it was set to Capture Time, switch it back to Custom Order and you should get back the last Custom Order that was set for that source. If the toolbar isn’t visible, choose View > Show Toolbar or press the T key.
The reason I said to pay attention to the selected source is that each source can have a different sort order setting. So if you tried to “come back” to a sort order but it is different, maybe you didn’t actually return to the same source. For example, maybe you were creating a Custom Order in a particular collection or folder, and when you came back it was to a different collection or folder which was set to Capture Time. A slide show is based on the current source.
If you want a certain Custom Order to stick, it’s a good idea to create and name a specific collection before sorting. Then you always know that collection has a custom order. I would definitely create a named collection for a slide show.
When you say you “sorted your catalog,” that’s why we’re saying to use more precise terminology because you can’t actually do a custom sort on the entire catalog (manual ordering is not allowed in the All Photographs collection, for example). So you must have been doing it in a more specific soruce.
By the way, it is definitely useful to lock down a sort order by hacking the filename (batch renaming with a Sequence Number added to the start of the filename). But you must be sure you will never change the order again, because if you do, it is not easy to renumber already-sequenced filenames in Lightroom Classic; you basically have to rename each one individually by hand in the Metadata panel. This is because Lightroom Classic batch file renaming is not powerful enough to do something like drop the first 3 or 4 characters of a filename and replace them with new characters. The only things you can do with the current batch renaming feature is add a new set of sequence numbers at the front without changing the old ones, or completely rename the files without using any of the previous filenames. (I keep hoping Lightroom Classic will add a proper batch renaming feature.) There are very powerful file renaming utilities out there, but if you run them on the original files Lightroom Classic will completely lose track of them all…which is why Lightroom Classic needs more powerful batch renaming features inside the application itself.
Thanks for the info. Very helpful.
I have again rearranged all the files and will now save everything as a Collection, but do I use Collection, Smart Collection or Collection Set in order to have the custom order/arrangement I created maintained and reacessible (for example, if I want to Sort by Filenmae on this same set of images then return to my custom order)?
Update. I am working in a Folder when I rearrange the files. I created a Collection, Collection Set and Smart Collection after selecting all of the files in the Folder, and all three of those rearranged the files using some sort order other than mine. The Folder instance maintains the custom ordering, but all of the others put the files into Capture Time, for reasons that I am unlclear on. Thankfully, the Folder still has the results of today's 3 hours of work... I really can't lose this ordering, so I think the Folder is where I need to be, always.
You should in general first create a collection before sorting your images for a slideshow. If you already sorted in a folder then you can still create a correctly sorted slideshow. When in your folder and in the slideshow module, hit the "create saved slideshow" button. This will generate a new collection that has the right sort order and that has all your slideshow settings saved as metadata in the special slideshow collection.
The Folder instance maintains the custom ordering, but all of the others put the files into Capture Time, for reasons that I am unlclear on. Thankfully, the Folder still has the results of today's 3 hours of work... I really can't lose this ordering, so I think the Folder is where I need to be, always.
Custom Order is allowed and preserved for a Folder or a Collection, but not allowed for Collection Sets and Smart Collections. So if you want to be able to manually rearrange and have that Custom Order be available, it has to be done in a Folder or Collection.
The restriction of Custom Order to Folders and Collections might be because of the different functions of each source type: