Images loosing some saturation in book mode

[default1jqjaoshavdj]

Anyone had the issue of everything looking perfect in the develop module but when images are droped into the pages of the book module they are loosing colour intensity?

The thumb nails look correct at the bottom, so it's all very odd.

It's also not happening to all the images it seems glitchy and sporadic.

[johnrellis]

You may have a color profile assigned to your display that is incompatible with LR. To test that quickly: 

http://www.lightroomqueen.com/articles-page/how-do-i-change-my-monitor-profile-to-check-whether-its-...

[Use the blue reply button under the first post to ensure replies sort properly.]

[Tony_See]

Following on from Johns question is your system recently calibrated?

Please also post you LR and OS versions.

[default1jqjaoshavdj]

Big Sur 11.1 updated about 2 weeks ago. 

Lightroom classic 10.1

[default1jqjaoshavdj]

Hi,

I'v been on the online chat with Abobe and the colour profile looks good, It only happens to the odd images from the same the shoot and they have all been treated and edited in the same way. It's never happened before & I'v been using lightroom for 10 years. It started about a month ago. It also now happens when I export and edit from within lightroom into photoshop, I don't make any colour corrections but maybe get rid of a mark etc, when it saves back into into lightroom as an edit it looks fine exactly as I want in develop mode. When I drop it into the book the colour flattens, the thumb nail looks fine etc. I know it has saved back as tiff file and the original is a jpg but this never used to happen before. My workflow between photoshop and light room and all modules always looked the same. So something odd is happening and It is very frustrating.

[GoldingD]

Roll back to v10.0 and see if that helps.

[default1jqjaoshavdj]

How do I do that through the adobe cloud? thanks

[default1jqjaoshavdj]

Ok I'v just checked it's very easy thanks 👍🏻

[Bob Somrak]

On highly saturated images there is a difference in the display between the Library and Develop modules with the Develop module being more saturated.  The Book module displays like the Library module, not the Develop.  I think this is because the Develop module uses a different profile than the rest of Lightroom.  I see this on my Imac 10.15.7 and Lr 10.1

[D Fosse]

Yes, in principle, but you need to have a very wide gamut monitor to be able to see that. It would have to cover considerably more than Adobe RGB. It's possible you could see a very slight difference on a DCI-P3 display - not because it's bigger than Adobe RGB, but because it's different. Some colors might be outside Adobe RGB but inside DCI-P3. But I would think it's mostly insignificant. The eye isn't very sensitive to subtle changes in already high saturation.

[default1jqjaoshavdj]

Ok, the reason why I can't work out why it's happening and I think it's a glitch but just wondering if it might be something different is because it doesn't happen accross the whole batch of images from the same shoot. So when looking at the saturation of all the images from the same shoot they all look good in Library and Develop module. The issue is that most of the images look good in the book module (containing similar images from the same shoot) but it's only a handfull of images that loose the saturation when added to the book pages but other images stay correct. This is why it's affecting work flow because it's not consistent how it's working. This is also why I don't believe it to be a profile issue.

[johnrellis]

"and the colour profile looks good"

The only way to determine if it is "good" is by temporarily assigning sRGB to the display and seeing if the issue still occurs, as described in the link above. You haven't confirmed that you've tried that yet.

Differences in color between Develop and the other modules is typically caused by an ICC display profile that either doesn't conform to industry standards or is incompatible with LR due to LR limitations or issues with the graphics driver. (LR uses different code for displaying images in Develop than in the other modules.)

[Use the blue reply button under the first post to ensure replies sort properly.]