In prior versions of LR, after importing a photo into PS, editing, and saving back into LR, the photo file would show up AFTER the >NEF photo in the filmstrip (like a before & after edit view). Now it shows up BEFORE the >NEF photo file. This is really throwing me off. Is there any way to get the ,psd file to save after the original .NEF photo?
(I just started using LR Classic on my desktop on Windows 10)
Thank you for any assistance.
I have the same question!
With 'Filename' sort set (A>Z) My TIFF (with an added '-Photoshop' suffix) from Photoshop appears before the DNG original!
Whereas in Windows File-Explorer the two files sort 'alphabetically' as expected.
I think I may have just fixed it.(After an hour or so of going back & forth with messaging "help" from Adobe with no resolution.)
In the Library Modual, under Edit>Preferences Go to the External Editing tab...at the bottom I changed the Edit Externally File Naming: IMG_0002.psd (sample shown)
Template: (To) Filename (from the dropdown choices)
I went back and tried editing in PS and saving back to LR and the edited .psd came after the NEF file in LR.Hopefully, it will continue this way...I hope it will help you as well.
"I think I may have just fixed it."
Hmm, this reply from 5 hours ago just appeared after I posted.
"Template: (To) Filename"
So it sounds like your previous naming template was producing names such as "a-edited.psd", which comes after "a.nef" alphabetically.
"Hmm, this reply from 5 hours ago just appeared after I posted."
Had the same thing happen on a post this morning that appeared to have no replies. After entering my reply to older posts appeared!
"In prior versions of LR, after importing a photo into PS, editing, and saving back into LR, the photo file would show up AFTER the >NEF photo in the filmstrip (like a before & after edit view). Now it shows up BEFORE the >NEF photo file."
It depends on the settings you have in Preferences > External Editing
- If you have enabled Stack With Original, then the version produced by PS will be stacked on top of the original and thus will always appear first.
- If you haven't enabled Stack With Original, then first make sure that you have View > Sort > Ascending and View > Sort > Filename or View > Sort > Capture Date. Then the behavior depends on the Edit External File Naming Template set in Preferences > External Editing:
-- If the original is named a.nef and the edited version is named a.tif, then a.nef will come before a.tif because "a.nef" comes alphabetically before "a.tif".
-- But if the original is named a.nef and the edited version is named (say) a-edited.tif, then a-edited.tif will come before a.nef because because "a-" comes alphabetically before "a.". LR differs from Windows File Explorer because LR sorts by the entire filename (e.g. "a.nef" and "a-edit.tif"), whereas it appears File Explorer sorts first by the base filename (e.g. "a" and "a-edit") and then breaks ties by sorting by the extension ("nef" and "tif"). The base filename "a" comes before "a-edit" alphabetically, so "a.nef" comes before "a-edit.tif".
If this doesn't help sort things out for, then tell us the full filenames of the original and the edited version, the setting of Preferences > External Editing > Stack With Original, and the settings of View > Sort and View > Sort > Ascending/Descending.