Has anyone else noticed the SPot Removal tool being very slow in LR5? I don't even mean when painting a selection. Just moving the mouse around the screen is sluggish and jittery for my on my Win7 system.
Thanks for any suggestions,
Thanks. I've pretty much gone throught the list and nothing jumps out as a possible fix. I'm using a 2.93 GHz Intel Core i7 iMac with 8 GB of ram. I used seperate catalogs for each shoot and merge them into my main catalog after editing, so my catalogs are small (the current one is only 241 photos). I use 20 GB of camera raw cache and always generate 1:1 previews before editing.
Another data point I suppose.
I've got a modest dual-core Windows 7 machine, 8gb memory, nvidia 8800GT card. (Steve! you could simulate nuclear explosions with the the kit you have )
I've found that spot removal is slow, laggy as described in this thread ... when I use my wacom Pen & Touch tablet.
When I use my mouse (a microsoft sidewinder x5), I have no problems! I can even leave the tablet attached.
I've tried it with all adjustments disabled, enabled with and without lens correction. The behaviour is consistent with all other observations: that doing the adjustments early and before lens settings is fastest. However, I find it usable even in the worst use-case -- just not using the tablet. Mouse is ok.
I also notice that when I quit lightroom, my tablet freezes for about 15 seconds then re-activates.
I wonder if the slow spot removal is actually mouse-driver related
... just supposin'
Thank you Hans!! I was ready to pull my hair out with the abysmal performance of the new healing brush when I ran across your idea to try my mouse. You are spot on (at least in my case). Using my Wacom tablet the performance is totally unusable, but using my Kensington trackball to paint with the healing brush the performance is quite acceptable. Very strange! I wonder if the pressure or angle inputs from the tablet are causing LR5 to go wonky...
Hi, I'm glad that it helped.
There was another post which suggested altering the 'tip feel' and 'tilt sensitivty' to soft and low (my wacom does not have the tilt sensitivity setting - the poster was using an intuos 5).
When I set the tip feel to soft (and the eraser as well ... why not? ) I found that the performance of the tablet improved. To the extent that for simple adjustments, I could use the tablet. Complex ones still lag.
I'm glad moving to the kensington worked for you but I have one and it has the "jerky" cursor problem. What settings are you using? Also I've tried lens correction profiles on and off with no change. I think I have an actual mouse around somewhere. If I find it I will try it and let you know.
I have the same problem. My Wacom Intuos5 does not work well with LR5. If I begin to highlight using the spot healing tool the whole program freezes for minutes at a time. If I use my Logitech mouse it works fine. I have tried turing Windows Ink off and on, turning the "tablet services" off and on and varying the tip effects all to no avail. I downloaded the new Wacom Intuos driver dated 09/03/2013 last night and installed it. If anything it made it worse. Wacom support has been next to useless. Wacom has a forum for Euopean users but not for North Amercian users. On the EU forum people are having the same problems. Botton line arrogant Adobe has released a very buggy LR5 and Wacom has not faced up to the problems with it tablets.
A work around I use is this
pan the cursor while in spot removal to your undesirable area then release space
It sounds like hard work, but subsides the infuriation of the dead cursor in spot removal mode.
When Lr5 becomes too slow due to too many spots I export my image as tiff and re-import it again into Lr so I can continu working with it. It's not more then a workaround but it saves me a lot of time and frustration...
When you export from Lightroom, the Export dialog allows you to check "Add to Catalog" so you can avoid the step of re-importing.
After backing up my original RAW files from my camera, I convert to DNG creating a second copy. If you export from Lightroom to TIFF, the file is about 8-10 times larger than if you export to DNG.
My Wacom Intous seems to work better when connceted directly to the computer. I do not use the wireless any more. When the Spot Healing slows, I use my computer mouse, then I try restarting Lightroom. I usually end up going to Photoshop in frustration.
Sometimes the Wacom loses control and makes continuous clicks causing all kinds of trouble. I disconnect it from the computer, Stop the driver, and re-start the driver.
I am very disappointed with the performace of my Wacom Tablet. There have been multiple problems since I purchased it. I never had a problem with my Wacom 2. I am also very unhappy with the Wacom support team. They either do not know what to do, or they are trying to hide the fact that there are serious problems with the tablet.
I'm getting the same problem with the healing brush, and the adjustment brush. It starts to slow down as soon as I select a spot, then there is a 1 to 2 second lag with every motion even brush re-sizing. Turning off profile corrections makes it better, but it's still a little slow.
The only way of speeding the brushes up is by disabling temporarly the detail and lens correction tabs.
Unfortunately they are expensive in terms of calculations.
That doesn't mean that Lightroom couldn't be faster....it could be WAY faster.
Remember that Lightroom and Photoshop are very different, there is no point in comparing them.
Lightroom is non-destructive wheres Photoshop works on pre-transformed pixels (you can see that it slows down quite a bit when you start using smart filters).
Hope Adobe will fix the performance issues in Lightroom when the 5.2 comes out...
The team recently found and fixed a slowdown problem related to tracking the spot tool's cursor (mouse position) when lens corrections are enabled. This fix will be in the final Lr 5.2 release, which will be available very soon. Hope this will resolve some of the problems you are experiencing.
This is refreshing news Eric.
Thanks for the update, this is definitely a good news.
The cursor is less jerky in LR 5.2 but the problem is still not fully solved.
With Lens Profile Corrections enabled, the spot tool will only work on a spot at a time. If I try to draw a correction, a curve, for instance, the spot tool draws a straight line between the point at the start of the curve and the point at the end of the curve.
The only way to avoid the problem is, as before, to disable profile corrections
I found this thread whilst looking for a LR3.6 issue (yup I'm back level). I found that profile corrections disabled makes a difference to my problem too. What I also noticed was that using my old Wacom Graphire tablet the spot tool was utterly useless but using my mouse it was just fine. I use spot tool a lot and wondered why it "suddenly" went slow - it was because I had picked up the pen (for other reasons) when I don't usually use it for spot healing in LR.
So other than turning off profile corrections for spot healing it may be worth considering using your mouse rather than your tablet. It is what I'll be doing from now on.
Penderra, THANK YOU for this post. I was going nuts.
My main issues were:
1) The diameter/size of the Radial filter was uncontrollable.
2) When trying to paint with the brush -- it just blotch painted huge areas.
I un-checked profile corrections --- and wham-o the problem was fixed.
ADOBE -- this issue is still a huge problem in Lightroom 5.7.1 - released DEC 13, 2014. You guys should get this solved already.
Experiencing same problems in Lightroom CC (2015).
I'm going to look for a new LR CC thread but posting here for now.
Using iMac 5K
AMD Radeon R9 M290X 2048 MB
Wacom Intuos 3. Performance with tablet slower than mouse but still lots of lag with the mouse. Again, slower when 1:1 but also plenty of lag when FIT.
Anyone having similar experience with LR CC - thoughts much appreciated?
2013 - 2015 - 2 years and Adobe don't fix this problem yet. Very Sad
Just what I was thinking. Adobe is getting more and more like Google...
These are basic functionality problems. FIX THEM.
Yes, very very frustrationg. I am wasting my time trying to spot heal or clone.
Adobe - this problem still exists and now with other tools such as the radial and gradient as well. New coding needs to address this as you are making your own program unfit for professional use. It is destroying workflow.