Combining Mixamo animations in Blender mangles most characters but not XBot or YBot

[DrLeary]

I'm playing around with Godot and I want to have a 3D character with multiple animations so I can learn how the whole playing and blending of animations work. Since I am no 3D artist, nor animator, some googling led me to Mixamo where I got some characters and some animations to work with.

I've been following the process described in this YouTube video for "fixing" the Mixamo files and combining multiple animations into one: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3Hk9ljcS1Ro.

Doing this manually in Blender sort of works, but is error prone and time consuming, so I found this script https://github.com/Johngoss725/Mixamo-To-Godot/blob/main/Mixamo_RM_Godot.py which I further modified and adapted to my needs.

Now I can basically run this script and have it combine 150 different animations without skins and a single charachter with skin in a minute or two. Great success!

Except it only works with the XBot or YBot charachters, all other charachters I've tried this with results in a weirdly mangled character and I cannot figure out why...

Steps to reproduce:

• New blender file -> Delete everything
• Import XBot.fbx (I choose Automatic bone orientation and Ignore leaf bones)
• Apply all transforms
• Select the Hips bone
• In Graph Editor select the Location keyframes -> Scale, Z, .01
• Rename the action to T-Pose
• Import Walking.fbx (I choose Automatic bone orientation and Ignore leaf bones)
• Apply all transforms
• Select the Hips bone
• In Graph Editor select the Location keyframes -> Scale, Z, .01
• Rename the action to Walking and stash it
• Delete the animation armature
• Back in the original XBot armature I open the NLA editor and select the stashed Walking action
• Success!

Repeat the same steps for pretty much any other character (for example Dreyar) and you end up with a mangled animation...

I've messed around with various scripts and tools that all purport to handle this process automatically (i.e Mixamo -> Blender -> Godot) and they all have the same problem (in addition to many other problems) where they work with the XBot and YBot charachters, but none of the others.

Any clue what I'm doing wrong here or how to fix this? Blender, and FBX-files in dropbox link.

https://www.dropbox.com/s/ubrbwce8uxhvukw/Mixamo%20Issue.zip?dl=0 

[Ussnorway · Accepted solution]

Mixamo is free software and you get what you paid for

Why = Fbx has been changed and old model are different to new... Many are different 3rd party software made

If you are seeking good 3D animation on Windows then Iclone with 3D exchange is the best but it isn't cheap as Adobe, doesn't run on Mac and is not subscribion based

[defaultck66bhfzc28k]

Ussnorway,

I've read a few of your comments, you seem to have a bad attitude. I suggest you take a break from posting in forums until you learn to be more corteous.

[DrLeary]

Maybe it's my whole mental picture of how this should work that is wrong...

The way I understand it an animation is just a set of keyframes along a timeline, each representing the location and rotation of a given bone at a given point in time, along with some settings for how to interpolate between each keyframe.

Based on this it would seem logical that as long as my characters share the same skeleton with the same bones I should be able to apply the same animation to them with the same result. I understand there is a little more to it than that, but that is the basic consept, right?

But it seems that Mixamo does some "magic" when retargeting animations that I don't understand. The "easy" solution would be to download each animation for each character from Mixamo, but this is slow and tedious. It works for the XBot and YBot without downloading separate animations for each, so it should be possible to retarget them to other characters as well, right?

[Ussnorway · Accepted solution]

yes your mental image is sound but the key point "same skeleton with the same bones" is where things go astray

back in 2019 it was Fbx A and last year as an xmas gift Adobe changed things to Fbx B... bone names get changed and they don't line up like they did before so I use Iclone* to retarget my models to a base set

*its actually 3Dexchange that does the retarget and Iclone makes the animations\ vids