Generative Fill Guidelines and Censoring

[byronw41971227]

I have some photographs where I would LIKE to change the shirt or clothing of some of my family members.  These are MY photographs that I have taken over the years.   A couple of the photographs are of shirts that are somewhat revealing in nature, NOT nudity, kind of low cut in nature.  If I select the shirt with a selection tool, and try to change the shirt or top using Generative Fill, I get the dreaded Notice that my request violates the Guidelines.    NOTE:   I am NOT creating nudity, or removing nudity, simply trying to replace a Woman's shirt, and a Male Shirt, (Old Tank Top).    am simply trying to create NEW shirts.   So, I do not understand what guideline I am violating.   Again, these are OLD images of mine, where I am just trying to release shirts with NEW shirts. 

Now, here is the WEIRD part.   After I got the guideline notice, I tried to see if I could create an entirely NEW document with Generative Fill, and I typed in, "Girl wearing Bikini walking on the Beach with the Ocean in the Background",  and it created it.    So, I can create a Bikini girl, but I can not replace a semi low cut shirt on a woman, or a tank top on a male.    Can somebody explain a way to get around this, or will this be fixed soon?

[robertw44482386]

Having this issue exactly. Wake up Adobe. People have breasts and we have to retouch the material that clothes them, just the same as bellys ankles and elbows.

[byronw41971227]

I am sure they will at some point reconsider their Guidelines, but it does seem a little heavy handed to not allow Subscribers to use the tool when NOTHING is wrong with the photos we are trying to fix.   It is not like we are trying to create NUDITY at all.    And regardless, nudity is part of Photography, as long as the nudity is not pornography, or of children.  Then it is STRICTLY against the law, and Adobe could simply report it.    So, I expect Adobe to fix this issue at some point.

[benjamin_0535]

You can request a less revealing or more general clothing change, which bypasses some of the restrictions. Otherwise, you can just use another editing tool with fewer limitations for this type of edit. This will work better for your request. Good luck!                                                                                                , ,

[davescm]

@SheldonvL Please read the community guidelines before posting.
https://community.adobe.com/t5/using-the-community-discussions/adobe-community-guidelines/td-p/47881...

Dave

[byronw41971227]

If something was said, or posted against the Community rules, please just say so.   When you post a link to the rules, it appears as though you are saying something was violated, and we have to GUESS what was violated.

So, please, just advise us, of what was a violation.  I am quite sure NOBODY meant to violate any community guidelines, we just asked a simple question.

[robertw44482386]

@davescm This is extremely unhelpful. Why post this reminder without pointing out what the issue is

Passive aggressive bot-posted nonsense like this should be against community standards.

[davescm]

@byronw41971227 @robertw44482386 The post I was responding to, with the link to the guidelines, has since been removed.

Dave