New Masking Tool.... and everything that is wrong with it (LOCKED—Duplicate Thread)

[Tanja2014]

as we all know the new masking edge tool has.. well lets say it kindly.... has grave issues.

this is not about noobs having problems to create a good mask. many people who complain have years any years of experience.

it´s about the new tool working WORSE than the old refine edge tool.

there are dozend and dozend of complains (adobe seems not to care about or just denies the problems exist).

here is a video (using CC2017) that explains in 40 minutes what´s wrong with the masking tool it and gives some help how you can still make use of it.

still..... ADOBE HAS TO FIX THIS!!!

BREAKDOWN: Select and Mask vs. Refine Edge - Photoshop CC - YouTube

[melissapiccone]

Are you choosing to ignore my responses in the other thread? Let's see your personal examples. In CC 2017 it's fixed for me. The Photoshop Team is genuinely interested in real examples. Provide me some and I'll pass them along.