scene edit detection not working

[default4vn64ifayge9]

scene edit detection not working on 24.1.0 ... I need to Quit the program and re-open my project file for Scene Edit Detection to detect scene cuts again

[mattchristensen]

@default4vn64ifayge9 I'm sorry to hear that. Could you let me know if you're on Mac or Windows, and which version of the operating system, and also which GPU you have? Thanks.

[default4vn64ifayge9]

MacOS 14.1.2 (23B2091) , 16" Macbook Pro M3 Max 16-core GPU

[default4vn64ifayge9]

MacOS 14.1.2 (23B2091) on M3 Max 16" Macbook Pro. 16 core GPU

A


ALEX TE
video | creative
[personal info deleted by mod]
<>

[Guest]

Following. This randomy happens to me as well, on macbook pro m2.

[mattchristensen]

@default4vn64ifayge9 Thanks, looks like you're up to date. Do you see this happen often enough with a certain clip or type of clip that you could share with me to try and reproduce the issue? 

[default4vn64ifayge9]

it happens every time. It works the first time I open Premiere. And then I have to quit the program, re-open the project and then the Scene Cuts work again.

[mattchristensen]

@default4vn64ifayge9 How long are the clips that you're running through Scene Edit Detection?

[Mr.De]

Happening to me as well for the last month and some. I've found the same fix as you did which is to re-open premiere pro and then it works but this is so frustrating. I got update 3 days ago and I thought it will be fixed but still not! Adobe needs to look into this issue!

[mattchristensen]

We've made a change to address this in the latest Premiere Pro (Beta) version 24.2 build 78. If you have been seeing this issue, could you try updating to the Beta from today or later (make sure you are on that version I mentioned) and seeing how it works for you? Thank you.

[Citizen_Sam]

Hey @mattchristensen ! My team finally updated from Premiere 2023 to Premiere 2024. We use scene edit detection daily, and have noticed it's quite slower in 2024.6.4. The same file took 4 minutes to scene edit detect in 2024, versus 26 seconds in Premiere 23.4.0.

We have recreated this error on three of our machines, all running of the same network/san, etc.

Any tips?

[mattchristensen]

@Citizen_Sam While updating, why not update to 2025? Two questions for you:

1. What are the specs of the system? Mac (Intel or Apple silicon?) or Windows? What CPU/GPU? Which OS version?
2. If you download and install Premiere Pro (Beta) from Creative Cloud (go to the Apps section then Beta), you'll get version 25.2 Beta installed next to your existing 24.6.4. How does the Beta 25.2 perform?

Thanks!

[Citizen_Sam]

Hi @mattchristensen ! Thanks so much for your prompt reply.

We're not planning to go to 2025 yet because we like to stay a year behind unless there's a compelling reason to update sooner that specifically addresses our workflow.  2023 has been absolutely wonderful to us.

Workstation...
Windows 10 Pro verseion 22H2
Intel Xeon Gold 6242R CPU @ 3.10GHz 3.09GHz
96GB Ram

64-bit operating system, x64-based processor

I installed Premiere 2025 beta on this machine and experienced the same issue. The file that takes 26 seconds to Scene Edit Detect in Premiere 2023 took five minutes in Premiere 2025 (so even a bit longer than 2024).

At the risk of muddying the troubleshooting waters... I, and other users, have also noticed that 2024 was slower to save and quit than 2023. Often hanging for a bit.

Thanks for your time on this!

Sam

[R Neil Haugen]

The completely rebuilt color management system for 25.x is a massive upgrade to Prmiere's capabilities. Stunningly so. That, for many shops, has been a major reason to move up.

[Citizen_Sam]

Hi @mattchristensen . Did the information I provided give you any insight into the issue?