Voiceovers Keep Getting Overwritten and Won't Start at Proper Place

[mikewilltravel]

Whenever I try and record a new voiceover, instead of the voiceover starting at the point I've selected in my timeline, it just starts recording a voiceover at the beginning of my video and overwrites everything.

How do I fix this? I searched online and checked voiceover settings and I couldn't find anything.

I made this screenshare video so you can have a visual and see exactly the issue I'm having: https://www.loom.com/share/d892f01ae3c842c89fdf5a310003d56c

Thanks so much!