Help to identify quality issues

[Andrew28402168wx0r]

Please point me to something that can result denial due to quality issues.

[daniellei4510]

It's always difficult to comment on illustrated fantasy art with respect to why it was rejected, but it might boil down to composition in these cases. The octopus images are too tightly cropped and I personally disdain the square format.  Their commercial value might also be questioned. There are questioned rendering errors in the tree woman.

[Jill_C]

The leg / knee is tilted at a wrong angle and seems disproportionate to the rest of the body.

[Andrew28402168wx0r]

Thank you. Any thoughts abotu Ctulchu?

[Jill_C]

Who or what is Ctulchu?

[daniellei4510]

The octopus thingy. These are examples where I say, "Just because AI can, doesn't mean you should." At least not for stock. A Ctulchu with Easter eggs doesn't scream "commercial value."

[Andrew28402168wx0r]

I just want to give people options they could never think about. I think that people who like Lovecraft will appreciate this one, but if not, i still would like to offer interesting ideas. It might not be popular or profitable, but i want to share this vision.

[daniellei4510]

Nothing wrong with that. But the whole idea of Stock is to make a profit (from the seller's point of view AND Adobe's). If that's not of interest to you, then there are other avenues to share your work. That said, I will repeat what I said earlier: they are too tightly cropped. Poor compositon is at least one of the quality issues here.

[Andrew28402168wx0r]

That is the monster on other two pictures. I often explore interesting themes by combining them, like, how the Easter would be celebrated in Lovecraftian world?

[daniellei4510]

OK...but besides an extremely limited group of Lovecraft fans searching for stock (that is, just about nil), who might be interested in spending expensive credits on such assets? 

[Andrew28402168wx0r]

I don't think they are extremly limited. Currently lovecraftian games dominate tabletop segment, and  that usually needs a lot of art. Many video games use this theme as well, it is one of the massive franchizes out there, and the best thing about it - public domain, that allows people to create what they want with it. Also regular fans of horror, monsters, and combination of cute and horryfying might be interested as well.

[Jill_C]

"Fans" of "horror, monsters, and combination of cute and horryfying" don't necessarily take out an annual Adobe Stock subscription in order to pay for such assets... 

[Andrew28402168wx0r]

Maybe. But those who are making content for them - might do.

[? ??]

Now all you have to do is prove your claim and provide us with information that proves it to be true.

[Abambo]

Rendering errors.

[Abambo]

There are obvious rendering errors. But who cares, it's anyhow a monster: