Honest feedback

[Sebastian30850957yv6u]

Dear Adobe-Community,

this picture was denied because of qualitiy issues.I can imagine which issues it had, i'm a bloody amateur.

I want to know , if this picutre is interesting or not. Technical issues are not the problem. What is your opinion from a creative standpoint, about the picture?

I try to become a digital art painter, so it would be very nice to hear if i have a future in this field, or should i let it be?

That would be nice to hear from you.

Have a nice day

Sebastian

[Jill_C · Accepted solution]

Why did you use PNG format? That's supposed to be used for images with transparent backgrounds.

[Abambo]

Why did you use PNG format? That's supposed to be used for images with transparent backgrounds.

By @Jill_C

Technically, if you download and open in Photoshop, you see that there is transparency.

But it makes not really sense:

[Sebastian30850957yv6u]

i didnt know about it, thank you ! I thought png. would be standard format, in case i dont really know what i do for now, i need to learn more about it.

[Jill_C]

Start by reading all of the Adobe Stock help pages which contain a wealth of informs which help you to become a successful stock contributor.

[Abambo]

If you are new to stock, you should consider these resources: https://helpx.adobe.com/stock/contributor/tutorials.html
Please read the contributor user manual for more information on Adobe stock contributions: https://helpx.adobe.com/stock/contributor/user-guide.html
See here for rejection reasons: https://helpx.adobe.com/stock/contributor/help/reasons-for-content-rejection.html
and especially quality and technical issues: https://helpx.adobe.com/stock/contributor/help/quality-and-technical-issues.html

If you are a generative AI contributor, please look into these instructions and follow them by the letter: https://community.adobe.com/t5/stock-contributors-discussions/generative-ai-submission-guidelines/td...

[Sebastian30850957yv6u]

There are many , thats great.

I think here in germany we say: "Noch ist Hopfen und Malz nicht verloren", means it's not to late to get better. 🙂

For every newcomer, dont give up !

[Abambo]

Aus Hopfen und Malz und Wasser und Hefe braut man Bier nach deutschem Reinheitsgebot! 😉

[Sebastian30850957yv6u]

Richtig, das ist lecker  das tut gut  das Bier nach deutschem Reinheitsgebot : )

Danke nochmal für die Tipps, ich geb jetzt richtig Gas und dann schauen wir mal. 

[Sebastian30850957yv6u]

Ok , sounds great ... i was a little bit hasty , should have read it before starting ! thank you

[Abambo · Accepted solution]

I want to know , if this picutre is interesting or not.

By @Sebastian30850957yv6u

No!

What is your opinion from a creative standpoint, about the picture?

By @Sebastian30850957yv6u

There is no real concept.

Technical issues are not the problem.

By @Sebastian30850957yv6u

One technical issue is your use of transparency that makes no sense, but it would have been better and more appropriate to reject this on commercial appeal. I won't judge the artistic value of this, but I can't imagine someone using this in an advert or as a wall paper.

[Sebastian30850957yv6u]

Thank you!

i think, that wouldn't be a advertise or wallpaper, too. There is no area for this, its just fantasy and painting. 

I think now, thanks to your feedback, that i have to learn more, and i will improve my technics !

Have a nice day  

[Abambo]

No, there is no space here for this kind of art.

[Ricky336 · Accepted solution]

Hello,

Stock is not art, so it is not the place for 'arty' types of assets.

I don't think there is any commercial appeal here. I don't think you have a future in this field of these types of assets; not on Adobe Stock anyway!

[Sebastian30850957yv6u]

I thought, that wouldn't fit it in here by adobe stock, too.

I shouldn't have uploaded it.

thank you for your honest feedback !

[Ricky336]

You have to think commercially!

[Sebastian30850957yv6u]

The question was answered , post can be closed.

! Feedback was great, helps me a lot. I changed in .jpeg and i will offer only stockphotos here. 

Thank you Jill_C, Abambo and Ricky 336 for their fast and helpful answers.

[Abambo]

You're welcome.

There is no correct answer (or correct answers...) :-).

We won't lock this thread, as it may be that other people may have questions or remarks that may be helpful. As for you, you may decide to answer new remarks or simply ignore them. There will be no harm on either side.

(you may need to unfollow this question, if you would rather not get e-mails when an answer comes in)

[Sebastian30850957yv6u]

Oh, ok yes of course maybe others will see it and will prevent mistakes, like mine. 😃 

i keep online ! thanks again 

[Abambo]

i keep online ! thanks again 

By @Sebastian30850957yv6u

There is no way to take it down. At least not, if it is not violating the forum rules (what your post definitely does not!).

Good luck with your further submissions.

[Sebastian30850957yv6u]

This is great!

For some reason i can't stop laugh about 'neu1234', apparently there was no time to name the file 🙂

I will report if things run better. 

Maybe the picture needs some explaining... i mean a flying wale... pff, what?! xD

Thank you for your time

Have a nice evening.

[Abambo]

It's a great file name for a site run by an American company. It has something exotic. 😂

[Jaume28175635bywv]

No one should tell you "let it be". Art is the most subjective thing there is. If you are happy doing what you do you should continue doing it. Another thing is whether you manage to convey the message or the emotions you intend to convey. But you will know this with time. Anyway, as I said, art is subjective and in front of the same work the sensations of different spectators can be infinite. I don't know how young you are, but I encourage you to persevere and not to be intimidated by the negative opinions or criticisms you receive. Don't give up!

[Abambo]

If you get asked questions you answer them. The asset is unfit for Adobe stock and I would guess also other stock sites. It may well fit into an art collection.

[Sebastian30850957yv6u]

Thank you Jaume28175635 and Abambo 

your answers hearten me. That'll be fine. I will report definitely if i gain success. I will continue with Art.