Looking for feedback on rejections based on quality issues

[reubenl58709281]

Hello, 

Looking for feedback on why the images have been rejected. Would appreciate any help, been struggling with acceptance of my images recently.

[Abambo · Accepted solution]

Besides holding the phone strangely, you have things like this in your images: 

You need to check your assets before submitting, if you want to avoid refusals.

This does not make sense: 

Watch the hands! This guy has a teleskopic thumb and other weird things with his hands:

The round button will earn you an IP violation, as Apple is fiercly defending their trademarks and look and feel of their phones.

Geometry errors like these: 

Texture errors like these:

Keyboards are very often faulty: 

blown out highlights, clipping: 

...and you should avoid adding things like this:

That's an easy addition, but difficult to edit out again.

[reubenl58709281]

Thanks!
Are there any more things you could point out? it would be quite useful for me to understand and note these down for future.

[Abambo]

Do as I did. Look at your assets, and if you find inconsistencies and things that simply are not right, edit them out. I did look into each of your pictures and found issues in each of them. However, as it takes time to critique assets thoroughly, I won't go deeper into the details. 

You have to check everything at 100%. Geometries need to be correct, textures need to be correct, anatomy needs to be correct... Generative AI makes generally a lot of rendering errors, as they don't know what they are rendering. Users often do not critically analyse the assets. 

[daniellei4510]

To name a few. You need to review your assets at a minimum of 100% (200% is better). If you are going for photorealistic AI, it must absolutely be photorealistic.

[reubenl58709281]

Thank you, I appreciate it. Any more issues you can point out? I want to make a list of things I should generally catch in my editing process.

[daniellei4510]

What to look for generally? Everything.

[jacquelingphoto2017]

Hi @reubenl58709281 ,

I look at the first three zoomed. I observe they have shallow depth, causing the edges to be soft. Also, they tend to have a blue tint. 

Best wishes

Jacquelin