Reason for rejection

[Ela73K]

Hello, i wanted to ask about the reason for rejecting AI graphics. The graphics were edited and corrected. T think its ok, but maybe someone will fins a reason.

[George_F]

What reason did Adobe give you for the rejection?  Just knowing the headline will be helpful.

[Ela73K]

Quality problems as usual

[moderator corrected HTML formatting error.]

[Abambo]

Quality problems as usual
By @Ela73K

You should always give us the reason, even if it is "as usual". 

As a side note: when pasting here from a translator or similar, you should use "paste without formatting".

[daniellei4510 · Accepted solution]

The devil is in the details. Not sure about the second image. Perhaps lacking in commercial value? But there could be some cleaning up to do in images one and three as per this example.

[Ela73K]

Could this really be the reason? It's a technique, you can't clean everything because the style will be lost.

[moderator corrected HTML formatting error.]

[daniellei4510]

I was not the moderator, so of course I can say for sure if this could really be the reason. Other than that, I'm not sure what random lines thrown out by an AI bot has to do with style here or what would be lost by cleaning it up.

[daniellei4510]

Can't, not can. Why do we only notice our typos AFTER we post? I suppose for the same reason we only notice flaws in an image AFTER we submit it.

[Nancy OShea]

Think about what customers want.  They need hard edges to make clean selections for use with other layers.   Try it yourself.  Soft edges are unforgiving and difficult to work with.  

As a Stock customer, I won't buy images that need sharpening and clean up. That's the Contributor's job.

After purchase, customers can easily soften and blur images if they want to. 

[Abambo]

Can't, not can. Why do we only notice our typos AFTER we post? I suppose for the same reason we only notice flaws in an image AFTER we submit it.

By @daniellei4510

You can correct your typos in your original post! That makes it more readable! 😂

No one is forbidding you to mark your edits as edits! 🤔

[daniellei4510]

We can??? Every time I click the "edit" link, nothing happens.

[Abambo]

Could this really be the reason? It's a technique, you can't clean everything because the style will be lost.
By @Ela73K

It's a guess. We are always doing qualified guesswork. You never know, what defect exacly lead to your refusal.

[Abambo]

Perhaps lacking in commercial value? 

By @daniellei4510

That has an own refusal reason.

If you check the patterns in the second image you detect some random pattern that should be there or not, but not both.

All assets show aliasing. That is typical for AI when they want to impress with sharpness. When you upscale, the upscaler does not always capture that.

[RALPH_L]

Nice images but if you look at them at 150-200% you will notice that they are all soft with nothing really focused. This may be what you want but, it could also be what the reviewers do not want.