Copy link to clipboard
Copied
Hi.
I completed texture in substance painter on all things seem ok. but when I export texture for Unity or PBR Metalic Roughness, I seen some strange stain on some part of my model. also in unity I put compression to None, but also I can see this problem.
when I disable Normalmap, stain will be removed. but I can't see any problem on normal map.
that looks like banding due to low bits per channel used in either the textures or your display settings.
Try a 16 bit export for your textures or 8 bit + dithering.
If that fails, try to set your display to 8 bit+dithering or 10bit.
The noise is normal, that's the actual dithering that reduces the banding artifact.
Other software may compress your normal map by default, so even if you use a 16bit normal map it will end-up looking bad because of the compression. This is a generally an accepted trade-off in game engines such as Unity to keep the memory footprint low.
You can try to change the setting of your normal map to uncompressed (or similar) to keep the raw quality. However this will icnrease the size of your texture
...Copy link to clipboard
Copied
that looks like banding due to low bits per channel used in either the textures or your display settings.
Try a 16 bit export for your textures or 8 bit + dithering.
If that fails, try to set your display to 8 bit+dithering or 10bit.
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
In 16 bit export, the problem still exists. but when I tried 8 bit + dithering export, the problem was solved. but it creates noise on normal map.
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
Go for 32bit
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
What exact format are you using?
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
I want use textures in Unity and Unreal.
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
The noise is normal, that's the actual dithering that reduces the banding artifact.
Other software may compress your normal map by default, so even if you use a 16bit normal map it will end-up looking bad because of the compression. This is a generally an accepted trade-off in game engines such as Unity to keep the memory footprint low.
You can try to change the setting of your normal map to uncompressed (or similar) to keep the raw quality. However this will icnrease the size of your texture in Vram.
I would suggest to stick with the 8bit + dithering.
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
Thanks.
you're Right, unity compress textures. so I disabled compression textures in unity.
So you suggest I set 8bit + dithering for all textures or only for Normal map?
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
It depends on the export preset you use, but generally yes dithering is only for the Normal map.