While OT from use of moderators, it illustrates why moderators are needed.... Ha, ha! And I'm too lazy to find a better thread for the turn this one has taken. I'll follow your lead....
I'm not arguing for a merge; there's no need that I see to change the current culture of each forum. But I'll share this example: a non-Adobe AE list I track has no subforums. Mac/PC, plugins (lots of esoteric), all versions, etc. But it is a forum of almost all pros, and it is rare to have a post that is not properly titled, including OT etc. Their (lack of) organization works just fine, and the content would be diminished if they had a Mac and a PC list.
The PPro forums reorganized when CS4 came on line, and the arguments for and against various subforum options approached the intensity of this thread (well, maybe approach is too strong a word for the rancor in this thread). This discussion of mac vs pc etc reminds me that the software used for the forums, while important, may be less important that some of the other decisions (pc vs mac vs no separation; version of the application in the forum; and content area).
For the new user who is/will be confused by any choices and the inevitable overlap, good search options are more important than multiple forums. But some Adobe forums have different needs from other Adobe forums. But we've all seen applications (usually standalone) that have large numbers of subforums and sub-subforums, but do they really add enough to make it worth the trouble?
I realized in an excursion to the jive site, that, while I can turn off the indenting, I would not be able to turn off the ability of posters to split the thread into sub threads. I've become very linear in dealing with these forums. Yes, I can adapt, but that could be one of the most significant changes in dealing with content.
... View more