P: Full Screen Preview works incorrectly with selections

[johnrellis]

Full Screen Preview (F) works incorrectly with selections when invoked from Grid view (G), though it does work correctly when invoked from Loupe view (E). Full Screen Preview should work just like Loupe view (and it does, when invoked from Loupe view).

To reproduce:

1. Go to Grid view. Let’s call three consecutive pics A, B, and C.

2. Select A and B, with A most selected.

3. Go to Full Screen Preview; the most selected (A) is displayed.

4. Click right-arrow. Pic C is displayed, even though it wasn’t selected.

5. Go back to Grid view and notice the original selection has been lost; just C is selected.

With Loupe view, right- and left-arrow cycle among the selected photos, and the original selection is not changed (only the most selected). Full Screen Preview should work the same way. And if in the recipe above, after selecting A and B, if you first enter Loupe view and then Full Screen Preview, left- and right-arrow work correctly, cycling among the selected pics A and B.

See here for another Full Screen Preview bug dependent on whether it is invoked from Grid or Loupe view:

http://feedback.photoshop.com/photosh...

[hillrg]

Sloppy, sloppy development.

[Bec Sowada]

Thanks for reporting this John. I have logged a bug about it.

[johnrellis]

Thanks Becky.

[Bec Sowada]

This has been fixed in the Release Candidate of Lightroom 5.2, available now at http://labs.adobe.com/technologies/li...

[johnrellis]

Thanks for the update.

[johnrellis]

Unfortunately, this has not been fixed in LR 5.2 RC. The recipe above still shows the same behavior as in LR 5.

[Bec Sowada]

I understand better now what is happening. Currently, the arrow keys act in full screen the same way they do in the module behind full screen. So, if you enter full screen mode from Grid, and have a few images selected, then press the arrow key, Lightroom will deselect the selection and move to the next image past the selection (the same way it does in grid mode without full screen). We have received feedback that customers would prefer Full Screen to always work like Loupe, so I have sent the bug back for further review. In the meantime, there are two possible workarounds.

1. Go to Loupe mode before going to Full screen.
OR
2. If you go to full screen from grid mode, use Ctrl+arrow keys to go to the next/previous image without losing the selection.

[johnrellis]

Thanks for the update.

[FeedbackCommunityMember]

This has NOT been fixed in 5.2.

[FeedbackCommunityMember]

I should have read further before commenting above. I understand why it's doing that now, but still agree with the OP that this feels like a bug. On the backend it makes sense that since we're still technically in Grid, that it acts like it's in Grid, but visually, we feel like we're in an advanced Loupe, so it should act like Loupe.

I second the "feature request" for changing it to respond like Loupe mode.

[JohnRolfeEllis]

This is fixed in LR 6/LR CC 2015. But another bug was introduced -- flagging or rating a photo in Full Screen Preview now affects all the selected photos, rather than just the current one: http://feedback.photoshop.com/photosh...