Thank you Doug! This solved my problem! Yes, Crop Marks were checked (I thought these would benefit the printing company so they could determine the bleeds - but turns out it isn't a requirement, and it adds an extra 0.16 inch to the size) so I just unchecked it, made the offset to 0, and remove the bleed on the Inside (so there are bleeds on Top, Bottom, and Outside only) Thank you so much!
... View more