Skip to main content
Participant
December 7, 2022
Question

MacBook Pro (M1 Max) vs PC (i9-1300k or Ryzen 7950x) with RTX 3080 or higher GPU

  • December 7, 2022
  • 4 replies
  • 776 views

Hi All,

 

Would anyone have insight into how the highest-end MacBook Pro (16", 64 GB RAM, 10-Core CPU, 32 Core GPU) stacks up against a high-end PC (64 GB RAM, i9-13900k or  Ryzen 9 7950X with a RTX 3080 GPU or higher GPU) concerning speed and performance in complex Premiere Pro and After Effects projects.

 

I need to upgrade my system and willing to invest in a high-end system to improve, optimize workflow - make it lightning fast where possible. 

 

The convenience of a Mac laptop would be great and comparably the same price assuming it's in the same performance range of a high-end PC for PP/AE.

 

Thanks in advance!

This topic has been closed for replies.

4 replies

Nidhogg Studios
Participant
December 12, 2022

All the setups you mentioned will work well for alot of video edit and AE but the main thing that alot people leave out is the scope of the projects and the codec that is used in the projects. That can change how stuff performs on high end platforms. 

These type of camera codecs can

Pro Res Raw

Pro Res HQ

Red Raw

Black Magic raw

H265 10Bit 

H264 8Bit

 

 

Legend
December 11, 2022

Currently, the 7950x underperforms in Premiere Pro because even the latest driver for its integrated graphics does not work properly with hardware decoding.

 

And in no way does even the most powerful MacBook Pro perform as well as a properly configured i9-13900K CPU-powered desktop PC with the aforementioned GeForce GPU and with the integrated Intel UHD Graphics 770 enabled. However, some motherboards disable the integrated Intel graphics disabled by default whenever a discrete GPU is also installed, forcing all hardware decoding onto the discrete GPU that generally does not perform as well in decoding as the Intel iGPU does. This almost completely negates the advantage of Intel over AMD since the built-in hardware decoders within the two CPUs would effectively become disabled.

 

And this is not to mention that laptops, even MacBooks, provide a significantly poorer performance-to-price ratio (or value). As in that MacBook is exceptionally expensive but performs no better than an average desktop PC that costs half as much money.

Ann Bens
Community Expert
Community Expert
December 7, 2022

Moved to hardware forum.

PECourtejoie
Community Expert
Community Expert
December 7, 2022

HEllo, you will find lots of benchmark results on puget bench, but I'm not sure if the Mac version is running in native or emulation mode. https://benchmarks.pugetsystems.com/benchmarks/?age=0&benchmark=PugetBench+for+Premiere+Pro&#results-table I've seen M1 MBPscore 1200 in their metric (enter M1 in the system spec column, then click twice on the results to sort by fastest), but maybe users of a M1 should have more relevant feedback, than a synthetic test.

Would the PC be a laptop? .