Skip to main content
Kimblah
Inspiring
October 20, 2017
Answered

Premiere CC 2018 Threadripper bad scrubbing performance

  • October 20, 2017
  • 22 replies
  • 16089 views

Hi,

Just build my Threadripper system (1950x, 32GB, 1080 Ti) and what I notice is that the scrubbing performance is pretty slow compared to my Intel laptop (i7 4790K, 32GB, 970M). I'm using GH5 ALL-I 4K files. Files are on SSD raid on Threadripper system and single SSD on laptop. Playback is ok, but scrubbing timeline is really bad.  Both systems are just installed with Windows Fall Creators update. Is premiere just badly optimized?

[Moderator note: moved to most appropriate forum.]

    This topic has been closed for replies.
    Correct answer Kevin-Monahan

    Team Threadripper:

    Please upvote this bug: Better Threadripper Support – Adobe video & audio apps

    Hope we can get this solved for you all.

    Thanks,
    Kevin

    22 replies

    bradyg92
    Participant
    May 1, 2018

    So I started having problems recently with Premiere Pro CC in the timeline scrubbing aspect.

    I have a Threadripper 1920x and nvidia 1080ti, 64gb ram on Windows 10. Premiere is installed on an M.2 OS drive.

    I also have a scratch disk, 512gb Samsung Evo Pro SSD.  This is where my previews and media cache go.

    I edit a lot of XAVC-S footage natively and usually have no problems whatsoever.  Which is what I'm currently editing with in this situation.

    I noticed importing a GoPro Cineform clip into my project from a Resolve Roundtrip, premiere would start to get crazy scrub lag.  You would think this codec would be buttery smooth as an intermediate codec.  I could not even zoom in on the timeline without having to press play and waiting for a few seconds before the change would occur. I would play my timeline, and would not be able to stop the timeline from playing. My Timeline would actually disappear on some occasions (just a grey panel).

    I came to this thread, tried a few things such as toggling on/off the play audio during scrubbing (this did absolutely nothing).

    I did a clean install of premiere. Nothing changed.

    Tried playing at 1/4 resolution. Nothing.

    I noticed someone said creating different folders for their audio media did the trick. Literally, all I did was create a new bin, drop the cineform clip in, and boom, smooth scrubbing and playback. IDK what the heck is going on with threadripper and premiere, but this is getting ridiculous.  Hopefully this temp fix works on other projects and this is not just some fluke. Keep this in mind.

    Love/ Hate relationship with Premiere.  Almost about to completely switch to Resolve especially since the Resolve 15 announcement.

    Inspiring
    February 25, 2018

    I have been having these issues with a similar setup as well. Threadripper 1950x with gtx1080 card. After literally months of troubleshooting, buying new drives and components, re-installs, and trying every little tip and trick on the internet, Adobe support helped me narrow down the issue to the graphics card. There is a problem with gtx 10 series cards specifically on Threadripper platforms in Premiere (I have not seen this issue on intel platforms with the same video cards). 

    To test this, open up Device Manager. Open up the Display adapters section, right click on your gtx10 series card and click update driver. Select "Browse my computer for driver software" then "Let me pick from a list of available drivers on my computer." In the list of drivers that comes up you should have an option for "Microsoft Basic Display Adapter." Select it and hit next to switch to that driver. 

    Your resolution will suffer, but once it is installed go back into Premiere and see if you have problems. For me, all problems are fixed.  

    Upon realizing this I ran out to Best Buy and picked up the last video card they had on their shelf, an AMD Radeon RX 550 and threw it in my computer. Playback and scrubbing was still crappy until I actually disabled my gtx1080 entirely. Now I can reliably reproduce the issue my toggling my gtx1080 from disabled to enabled in device manager.  

    If you all run the same test with the same result, please report the bug to NVIDIA here: NVIDIA Driver Feedback|NVIDIA

    Hopefully they can get a fix out to us sooner than later.

    Known Participant
    April 14, 2018

    Yeah right!?!? This would explain A LOT of my problems in Premiere. Everybody on here has almost the exact same build...1950X, ROG Zenith Extreme and GTX 1080/1080ti on M2 SSD. Anyways, I'm over Premiere I think. Resolve has my heart right now. Sorry Adobe!

    Known Participant
    January 23, 2018

    Hey all,

    I've learned some things in the last month since building a Threadripper 1950x system. Here is a list of things I have done to increasingly improve the performance of the Threadripper in AE and Premiere. Its not perfect yet but its getting faster the more I tweak certain things

    FIRST THINGS FIRST FOR PREMIERE***

    DONT CONVERT A PROJECT FROM AN OLDER VERSION!!!! It causes major playback issues. Create a new project from scratch OR import your project into the new version of Premiere and copy the old composition into the new comp.

    THEN TRY THESE:

    1) USE AN M2 drive for your cache!!!!!! I tried using a fast Intel SSD for my cache in After Effects (and Premiere) and noticed that the computer I use at work using an i7- 7700K was MUCH faster than my TR 1950X. Part of the reason is because it uses a Samsung NVMe drive for its cache. I changed my cache to run off my of seperate NVMe drive and the performance on a vector heavy project increased by almost 20% or so. **THE M2 DRIVE NEEDS TO BE SEPERATE FROM THE OS AND STORAGE DRIVE

    2) UNINSTALL RYZEN MASTER!!! It messes with your CPU processes. Once it was removed Premiere and After Effects performance improved.

    3) CLOSE OR UNINSTALL ASUS SONIC STUDIO. It messes with your CPU processes. Once it was removed Premiere and After Effects performance improved.

    4) DONT USE THE RYZEN POWER SETTINGS!!!!! Use PERFORMANCE POWER SETTINGS. Trust me

    5) If you are working on a complex After Effects comp with vector elements TURN OFF 'SHOW LAYER CONTROLS'. This speeds things up significatly

    6) USE AN M2 FOR YOUR OS AND APPLICATIONS!!!! The faster the M2 the better.

    7) UNINSTALL ASUS AI SUITE or any overclocking utility. This processor is a different animal from INTEL, it doesn't work the same way

    8) SET PROCESSOR AFFINITY TO 12 CORES FOR AFTER EFFECTS.....this should increase performance for now

    Follow these steps and your Threadripper will start to perform like a dream. KEEP IN MIND, this processor is AHEAD OF ITS TIME and Adobe needs to catch up to these new massive multi-core processors. In time After Effects and Premiere will scale with hyperthreading and your system will CRUSH. AMD has started something interesting..dont throw in the towel. The best is yet to come

    SPECS

    AMD Threadripper 1950X

    ASUS  ROG ZENITH EXTREME X399

    CORSAIR VENGEANCE 3000 MHZ 64GB  - **make sure to set your RAM timings manually in BIOS
    GTX 1080ti turbo 11GB

    Samsung Pro M2 for OS and APPS

    Samsung Pro M2 for CACHE
    ...the rest of the peripherals dont matter

    I hope this helps. I'm still tweaking and I'll post any discoveries I find. Bless!

    Participating Frequently
    January 15, 2018

    Buy folders I mean folders inside the premiere project if I have all my video files in music without organization in bins. Timeline will freeze up.

    Participating Frequently
    January 15, 2018

    They are on my c drive in video folder? Where should they be?

    PECourtejoie
    Community Expert
    Community Expert
    January 15, 2018

    Are the previews at 100% on both computers? What is the screen resolution on both machines?

    Participating Frequently
    January 15, 2018

    I usually have the previews at about 50%. I started converting the music to .wav because I thought Premiere liked .wav now I've noticed with the new premier you can use MP3 as are many other music files. Also now that I started using folders I am not having this issue but if I have the large Project without folders why does Premiere freeze up.

    Bill Gehrke
    Inspiring
    January 15, 2018

    Where are your media files?

    Participating Frequently
    January 6, 2018

    I have a threadripper 1950x a 1080ti gaming SC Black Edition and a 960 Pro boot 512gb. Scratch files going onto a 1-terabyte wd blue. I noticed that every time I add an audio file Premiere starts to freeze up and I cannot do anything. The play head freezes up and I cannot move the mouse sometimes. It is very strange if I delete the file from both the timeline and the folder it will go back to normal. I've noticed if I make folders for the music it goes away. Can anyone explain why this is happening? Note I'm very new to premiere! Only 2 months under my belt I bought this computer just to get over not being able to use the program on my laptop.

    Participating Frequently
    November 28, 2017

    I have another update.

    My main media was being accessed through the network, so i tried moving things to a local drive (stardom raid 5 drive, it is still a slow drive but its local). I found a very slight improvement but still not ideal, and again using a marker to scrub yielded very smooth scrubbing. So it got me to thinking to turn off "play audio while scrubbing" (edit>preferences>audio> then untick "play audio while scrubbing").

    Then boom, buttery smooth scrubbing.

    This is quite weird as my cache drive is raided ssd's reading and writing at 500MB/s plus.

    I do prefer to have audio scrubbing on, but in this situation i'll forgo that for buttery smooth scrubbing.

    Well, hopefully this helps as somewhat of a work around. Good luck

    dutchy_on_a_bike
    Known Participant
    November 28, 2017

    I tried the scrubbing with the marker and without and it didn't help. What I have worked out is that .MXFs are awful on the Threadripper, Long GOP or Intra frame. My ancient MacPro 5,1 with a GTX 980 flies though that stuff even with Lumetri. My solution was this; and it is not pretty. On my desk I have the MacPro 5,1 and the 1950x PC, from the Mac I access the .MXFs and use Edit Ready to transcode the files to ProRes, saving them back to the PC. The files never leave the PC. I then set my timeline to ARRI 1080P/25 and ALL IS GOOD!! NO DROPPED FRAMES. I'm lucky I don't need to export back to ProRes, all my work is exported h.264 for Online or TV Commercial broadcast. But there is definitely something wrong with the 1950x/Premiere combination. Mark

    Participating Frequently
    November 28, 2017

    Interesting, im also dealing with MXF's from the Sony FS7, 1080p and 4k 25fps.

    Did you try my latest workaround re-turn of audio scrubbing.

    I'm thinking it wont work cause it is essentially the same thing as scrubbing with the marker, but still worth a try to be sure.

    My issue seem to be more around the cached audio rather than the MXF video. For my setup i've cached the audio away from the MXF location. Im curious where do you cache your audio files?

    Im now finding that even with proxies turned off and accessing the files through the network (1gbps) with both the 1080p and 4k synced into a multi camera sequence in the preview window, im still getting smooth scrubbing.

    Participating Frequently
    November 27, 2017

    HI, im having the same issue.

    I want you to test something to see if it mimics my results.

    Drop a marker on the time line then grab the marker and scrub.

    Im finding im getting terrible scrubbing performance even with proxied media, but when i drop a marker and scrub the marker it scrubs as i would expect it to (nice and smooth). This suggest to me some sort of optimization issue.

    Let me know if this works for anyone else.

    My system specs

    1950x threadripper (creator mode)

    Asus zenith extreme

    gtx 1080 ti

    64gigs ram gskill class 16 pc3200 2133mhz

    Samsung 960 evo m.2 (OS and Apps)

    x2 Samsung 850 evo SSD (in raid 0) adobe cache

    Participating Frequently
    November 28, 2017

    FYI i did the PPBM test

    i got "1027" "36" "14" "44"

    I realize my hardrive speed is slow, but because im using proxies in my workflow this shouldn't matter.

    Also the fact that i can get smooth scrubbing by placing a marker and scrubbing the marker confirms this.

    Bill Gehrke
    Inspiring
    November 28, 2017

    https://forums.adobe.com/people/Te+Rurehe  wrote

    FYI i did the PPBM test

    i got "1027" "36" "14" "44"

    I realize my hardrive speed is slow, but because im using proxies in my workflow this shouldn't matter.

    Also the fact that i can get smooth scrubbing by placing a marker and scrubbing the marker confirms this.

    1. That 1027 second score for your disk system is a transfer rate of 36 MB/sec which is like trying to use USB2 for editing and is no way near enough for any kind of editing, even proxies.
    2. Your 44 second number is an impossible score for the CPU intensive timline export.  I have found that Premiere 12 does not remember export settings so may that was the problem.
    3. Your 14 second score for the strictly GPU score is right on the button for your GTX1080 Ti
    4. The 36 second score for the very complex H.264 timeline export is very good if it is correct but here is the score that a very satisfied Threadripper owner has:

    "34","52","13","158", Premiere Version:, 11.1.2.22

    dutchy_on_a_bike
    Known Participant
    October 30, 2017

    It has to be a Premiere/Ryzen/Cuda problem. Outside of Premiere I find all videos play fine, even 4K phantom vision but in Premiere 2017 or 2018 it is unusable.

    Premiere 6 plays fine. What to do?

    Bill Gehrke
    Inspiring
    October 31, 2017

    dutchy_on_a_bike  wrote

    It has to be a Premiere/Ryzen/Cuda problem. Outside of Premiere I find all videos play fine, even 4K phantom vision but in Premiere 2017 or 2018 it is unusable.

    Premiere 6 plays fine. What to do?

    Why is it that that I have had nothing but praise from several users.

    What motherboard are you using?

    Test your system with my PPBM.

    How many processes are running after bootup, see my desktop computer below.

    Your statement "Outside of Premiere I find all videos play fine" has absolutely no bearing on playing in an editor

    Report on your processes and what numeric version of windows