Skip to main content
Participant
July 4, 2018
Question

So is this whole multiple SSD drive setup Urban Myth or Fact?

  • July 4, 2018
  • 5 replies
  • 1268 views

Just building a new pc...and all over the Internet I keep reading and hearing about having multiple SSD's for OS, Scratch disks, Media and Project files etc. etc.

But I'm curious has anyone ever actually tested this? Or is this just what everyone keeps telling everyone else?

ie. I wonder if purchasing one high quality SSD and then a large Media Regular HDD...would effectively do just as well as these multi SSD setups?

Has anyone here actually compared the performance? Thanks for any shared experiences...either primary or secondary sources.

Thank you.

    This topic has been closed for replies.

    5 replies

    Participant
    July 8, 2018

    Thanks for all the comments...after all the research..the consensus from all is indeed this:

    a 'normal' SSD for OS/programs, an M.2/Nvme SSD for projects and much of the rest of the work,

    (I'll probably just install an extra standard Drive for extra storage.)

    As I've researched this build the fascinating discovery has been the Graphics card....

    it appears the 'myth' is more related to needing the latest and greatest Graphics card...I was all set to get a 1070 ti...but am wondering whether .a cheaper 1060 would probably do fine...

    Anyway thank you so much for all the replies here!

    Much appreciated.

    Legend
    July 8, 2018

    https://forums.adobe.com/people/Mavoz+Australia  wrote

    it appears the 'myth' is more related to needing the latest and greatest Graphics card...I was all set to get a 1070 ti...but am wondering whether .a cheaper 1060 would probably do fine...

    That actually depends largely on which CPU that you'll be using. A GTX 1070 Ti would be overkill for a system that has only a quad-core, non-hyperthreadable Intel i5 CPU. This is because unlike gaming which stress the GPU much more than the CPU, video editing stresses the CPU a lot, and can also stress the GPU depending on any effects that make good use of GPU acceleration.

    And if you do go lower on the GPU, be careful which one to choose: If the theoretical maximum memory throughput (in GB/s) of a given lower-end GPU is lower than the theoretical maximum throughput of the main PC's RAM, the CPU-only performance will suffer significantly.

    John T Smith
    Community Expert
    Community Expert
    July 7, 2018
    R Neil Haugen
    Legend
    July 7, 2018

    From the extensive results Bill has compiled, the last things I saw him recommend was a 'normal' SSD for OS/programs, an M.2/Nvme SSD for projects and much of the rest of the work, and if additional drives are used, internal SSDs where possible and Samsung T5 via USB3 for externals at need.

    And yes, he has the data referred to in other posts on this thread about the specific performance differences on many machines of the exact same high-use project file exported & logged.

    Neil

    Everyone's mileage always varies ...
    Stan Jones
    Community Expert
    Community Expert
    July 4, 2018

    A mod moved your post to the hardware forum.

    Here is the latest PPBM bench marking results. Bill Gehrke has done a great service for the community.

    BillG Video Editing Blog

    You'll get some feedback here.

    Quick bottom line: traditional harddrives are mostly for backup storage now if you have the option of enough SSD space to handle your editing workflow.

    Legend
    July 4, 2018

    There's what used to be a FORUM ( now called a subspace I guess ) called HARDWARE ...and you can find it listed where I made the little circle

    People used to do all sorts of tests (called BENCHMARK TESTS), and one guy who contributed a lot to forum even made his own benchmark test and people could post results to a sort of database thing... so everyone could see results.

    Aside from different speeds of memory, memory buses ( like old front Side Bus (FSB)) and cpu speeds and different seek times and Rpm's of HDD ( black drives etc.) and heat issues and graphic card specs, there's TONS of stuff to study and look into when buying or building a computer.

    Ultimately it comes down to YOU and what you intend to use your computer for, how dependable it has to be ( RAID 1 ? ) and the costs.

    Good luck !