Icons disappear when changing from boarder to fill with auto-animation

Hello!

Lately I wanted to get to know Xd a little better and wanted therefore to redesign an app I really do not like. In other words: I am quite new to Adobe Xd, but not Adobe in general. 

Here is my problem (sorry for the sloppy explaination):

I have a start page with a slide-out menu with the help from auto-animation. On this slide-out menu you will get the oppertunity to press on home to just close the menu, or you can go to a new page. When the button for a new page is pressed, I want the fill of my icons to change from home to the new page. It works perfectly on the button that is pressed when it changes from boarder to fill, but the button that was filled just dissapears instead of changing to boarder.

It is like boarder -> fill is ok, but fill -> boarder disappears?

I hope this gif can clear up my problem even better: https://i.gyazo.com/e2e93abfed6ef7ae5a62ff5c6af19d88.mp4

Hope someone can help me, I bet it is just a beginners mistake!