<cfinclude> = 2 Pages on 1 Page

I am using a  <cfinclude template="../MakeYourChoice/index.cfm"> on a page that once the coice is made the screen below will provide feedback.  

I just realized the  <cfinclude template="../MakeYourChoice/index.cfm"> is showing up at the top and at the bottom is the next screen that should NOT show up as two screens on one page.

How can I make this process as seperate pages without changing hundreds of lines of code?!? 

Thanks!