Skip to main content
Participating Frequently
Jun 29, 2006 10:05 PM UTC
Question

coldfusion or php?

This might be like asking which sport is the most popular while standing outside the superbowl, but I am trying to decide between CF and PHP for dynamic websites. I use DW8 and would like to try dynamic sites. I know nothing about programming but would like to learn one of the two. I know that PHP has a bigger following and CF is easier to learn (so I've read). Comments?
This topic is closed to new replies. Start a new post to keep the conversation going.

14 replies

Inspiring
Jul 6, 2006 4:23 PM UTC
Actually, since you picked the middle of Idaho, you could probably get
by with Spanish, or better yet - Basque. Just a silly bit of trivia,
but central Idaho has a large Basque population of sheep ranchers.

tclaremont wrote:
> If you live in the middle of Spain, it is probably best to speak Spanish. If
> you live in the middle of Idaho, it is probably best to speak English.
>
> CF and PHP are tools. You can accomplish much the same thing with either of
> them. The "better" tool is likely to be the one that allows you to co-exist
> among those working with you.
>
Translate
tclaremont
Inspiring
Jul 10, 2006 7:45 PM UTC
Somehow the idea of Basquing among the sheep ranchers in Idaho does not sound all that appealing!
Translate
tclaremont
Inspiring
Jul 6, 2006 4:23 PM UTC
Hey Enrico, you quoted "yourself" as saying something that was posted by Reno just a couple of posts above.

It almost seems like Reno and Enrico are one and the same person, doesn't it?

(as if we didn't know the answer to this mystery...)
Translate
tclaremont
Inspiring
Jul 6, 2006 4:17 PM UTC
If you live in the middle of Spain, it is probably best to speak Spanish. If you live in the middle of Idaho, it is probably best to speak English.

CF and PHP are tools. You can accomplish much the same thing with either of them. The "better" tool is likely to be the one that allows you to co-exist among those working with you.
Translate
Inspiring
Jul 5, 2006 7:54 AM UTC
it seems like php has more oppurtunities and is the one to be more stable
for the future.

"Mr. Brownie" <webforumsuser@macromedia.com> wrote in message
news:e81irf$ncm$1@forums.macromedia.com...
> This might be like asking which sport is the most popular while standing
> outside the superbowl, but I am trying to decide between CF and PHP for
dynamic
> websites. I use DW8 and would like to try dynamic sites. I know nothing
about
> programming but would like to learn one of the two. I know that PHP has a
> bigger following and CF is easier to learn (so I've read). Comments?
>


Translate
Inspiring
Jul 3, 2006 2:13 PM UTC
??One of its chief marketing points is
"Look! It's all tags! It's as easy to use as HTML!". They're not hunting
the seasoned developer with an approach like that, are they?

I will add to that by saying that seasoned developers would never be lulled
into thinking cf's percieved advntages outweighed it's disadvantages - but
the newbies would fall for the idea that "html is easy, html uses tags = cf
uses tags, it must be as easy as html"

A couple of years back i tried to read a file with cffile, but needed to do
it one line at a time - I was shocked to learn that something so basic could
not be done in cfml. The second thing we did (old company) was fall for the
"out of the box" thing to find that we had absolutely no drawing api
(drawing tags). I had sold the cf ideato my boss who later researched and
found out that both these thing could be doen in php adn that php was free
of charge and already installed on one of the servers!! Luckily, work around
weere easy to find, but still, I definitely experienced the issue of cf's
limitations.

I feel I should add to that by pointing out that these days it seems that
the official response seems to be "if it can't be done in cfml just use
java" - this flys in the face of the whole reason people buy cf in the first
place.

>>I don't think it's going to fall off the map any time soon

No, theres still plenty of newbs out there and still plenty of folk that
depend on it for existing websites. I am dissapointed to see the rather mass
exodus from cf to the java.php and .net world but i think cf can still do
okay in the market it aims for.






"Adam Cameron" <adam_junk@hotmail.com> wrote in message
news:rd7ts2b6ze6z$.fq93uz0y5y82.dlg@40tude.net...
>> Why say this - is it more to do with the inflexibility or to do with
>> there
>> being less demand for cf skills there days?
>
> I've been fortunate enough to not have to look for work in CF: both the
> jobs I've had so far came to me, rather than the other way around. And I
> know if I needed work again, my network is of sufficient size that I could
> get a job tomorrow if I needed one. So it's not the availability of work,
> no. I've never considered that.
>
> My findings with CF are probably best summed up by drawing a parallel to
> common arguments regarding <cfinsert> / <cfupdate> and <cfquery>. ie:
> <cfinsert> and <cfupdate> are OK as long as you hold your mouth the right
> way and only ever want to do exactly what those tags are set out to do.
> On
> the other hand <cfquery> gives you a lot more scope beyond what those tags
> offer.
>
> I've used <cfinsert> and <cfupdate> precisely ONCE, before I spotted the
> draw backs of having to code in the way Allaire second-guessed I should be
> coding; and actually the gains in using <cfquery> instead deeply outweigh
> the increased typing time (which is all it amounts to).
>
> I feel the same way about CF as a whole. CF is one big <cfinsert>.
>
>
>> Personally, I am fed up hearing of its demise and hearing from the
>> "professional" developers about how cf is a "toy" language for newbies.
>> Arrgggghhhh!
>
> I don't think it's going to fall off the map any time soon, but I also
> *do*
> think its niche is the newbie market. One of its chief marketing points
> is
> "Look! It's all tags! It's as easy to use as HTML!". They're not hunting
> the seasoned developer with an approach like that, are they?
>
> --
> Adam


Translate
Inspiring
Jul 3, 2006 1:30 PM UTC
> Why say this - is it more to do with the inflexibility or to do with there
> being less demand for cf skills there days?

I've been fortunate enough to not have to look for work in CF: both the
jobs I've had so far came to me, rather than the other way around. And I
know if I needed work again, my network is of sufficient size that I could
get a job tomorrow if I needed one. So it's not the availability of work,
no. I've never considered that.

My findings with CF are probably best summed up by drawing a parallel to
common arguments regarding <cfinsert> / <cfupdate> and <cfquery>. ie:
<cfinsert> and <cfupdate> are OK as long as you hold your mouth the right
way and only ever want to do exactly what those tags are set out to do. On
the other hand <cfquery> gives you a lot more scope beyond what those tags
offer.

I've used <cfinsert> and <cfupdate> precisely ONCE, before I spotted the
draw backs of having to code in the way Allaire second-guessed I should be
coding; and actually the gains in using <cfquery> instead deeply outweigh
the increased typing time (which is all it amounts to).

I feel the same way about CF as a whole. CF is one big <cfinsert>.


> Personally, I am fed up hearing of its demise and hearing from the
> "professional" developers about how cf is a "toy" language for newbies.
> Arrgggghhhh!

I don't think it's going to fall off the map any time soon, but I also *do*
think its niche is the newbie market. One of its chief marketing points is
"Look! It's all tags! It's as easy to use as HTML!". They're not hunting
the seasoned developer with an approach like that, are they?

--
Adam
Translate
Inspiring
Jul 3, 2006 12:07 PM UTC
>>Not such a problem because one doesn't *need* 1000s.

I was alluding more to the fact that the absence of a compepetive book
market, and the withdrawal from sale of one of the most popular books, could
be an indicator of how mainstream (or not) cf was - just in case this
mattered.

>>> To answer the original poster, I've been using CF for five years or so,
> now. It's *OK* (seesawing my hand as I say that), but if I had my time
> again I'd probably go with PHP.

Why say this - is it more to do with the inflexibility or to do with there
being less demand for cf skills there days?

Personally, I am fed up hearing of its demise and hearing from the
"professional" developers about how cf is a "toy" language for newbies.
Arrgggghhhh!

"Adam Cameron" <adam_junk@hotmail.com> wrote in message
news:11smrzmkfvx33.8auasvkqyuau.dlg@40tude.net...
>> With cf, not so many books (maybe one or two that are decent). With PHP,
>> thousands of books.
>
> Not such a problem because one doesn't *need* 1000s. The only one that's
> really helpful for getting up to speed is the CFWACK, as you mentioned.
> I've not read one since CF5, but if subsequent releases are maintaining
> their quality, they cover all the bases really.
>
> To answer the original poster, I've been using CF for five years or so,
> now. It's *OK* (seesawing my hand as I say that), but if I had my time
> again I'd probably go with PHP. CF's good for a learner, but the "hiding
> complexity" bit that is good for a learner gets annoying once one *isn't*
> a
> learner any more.
>
> --
> Adam


Translate
Inspiring
Jul 3, 2006 8:33 AM UTC
> With cf, not so many books (maybe one or two that are decent). With PHP,
> thousands of books.

Not such a problem because one doesn't *need* 1000s. The only one that's
really helpful for getting up to speed is the CFWACK, as you mentioned.
I've not read one since CF5, but if subsequent releases are maintaining
their quality, they cover all the bases really.

To answer the original poster, I've been using CF for five years or so,
now. It's *OK* (seesawing my hand as I say that), but if I had my time
again I'd probably go with PHP. CF's good for a learner, but the "hiding
complexity" bit that is good for a learner gets annoying once one *isn't* a
learner any more.

--
Adam
Translate
Inspiring
Jul 3, 2006 12:43 AM UTC
>>Are there any good books to learn from?

With cf, not so many books (maybe one or two that are decent). With PHP,
thousands of books. I was particulalry disappointed to learn that one of the
best coldfusion books around (oreilly learning coldfusion) has been taken
out of print through lack of demand. However, the CFWACK (see
www.forta.com ) book is still going strong and is very good.


"Mr. Brownie" <webforumsuser@macromedia.com> wrote in message
news:e88lgl$8mp$1@forums.macromedia.com...
> Are there any good books to learn from? I think I might learn faster if I
> could actually create CF (or PHP) websites as part of the book. I have
one
> such book on order at the library. It is "Dreamweaver 8 with ASP, PHP, &
CF"
> by Jeffrey Bardzell. It seems like it will develop all three as you go
along
> in the book. Are there any others that are similar to this one?
>


Translate
Inspiring
Jul 3, 2006 12:40 AM UTC
>> ColdFusion tends to be easier to learn if your coming from a HTML /
designer
background, because you can still use tags.

Kind of irrellavant really, as one still needs to learn javascript to do any
web developemnt, so the C style syntax is always going to be something one
needs to learn.

If you want to improve job prospects, best to go with php (much more work
around). If you simply need to build a site for yourself/client and have
extra money to spare (usually more costly to host and definitely mrope
costly to buy), go coldfusion .


"pete_freitag" <webforumsuser@macromedia.com> wrote in message
news:e81jn7$obp$1@forums.macromedia.com...
> Your thoughts are right on, PHP does have a bigger following, and
ColdFusion
> does tend to be easier to learn (though if you come from a C++ background
some
> might say php is easier to learn).
>
> ColdFusion tends to be easier to learn if your coming from a HTML /
designer
> background, because you can still use tags.
>
> Ofcourse your asking this question on an ColdFusion forum, most people
here
> prefer ColdFusion. What you might want to do is spend a day learning php,
and a
> day learning ColdFusion, decide which one you think will be easier for you
and
> pick it up. Your time spent on the opposing language will not be wasted,
since
> you will likley learn bascis of programming from both.
>


Translate