Comodo Standard SSL CFHTTP Keystore Problem

Can anybody help!

Payment processor Chargify updated their SSL from SHA-1 to a Comodo SHA-2 SSL. Well this has caused major problems on my end. CFHTTP now returns "Connection Failure" and nothing more.

I have:

• Downloaded the new cert from Chargify.com in .cer format.
• Used the keytool to import it to CACERTS sucessfully (Java version 1.4.2_19 Which should work)
• Restarted Coldfusion and that didn't work
• Also downloaded COMODOExtendedValidationSecureServerCA.cer and COMODOCertificationAuthority.cer  and added both CACERTS file via keytool import.
• Restarted Coldfusion and that didn't work.

I'm thinking if  they would have used Thawte or Verisign, I wouldn't have this problem. Anybody have any suggestions??? I've been pulling my hair out for the last 8 hours trying to figure this out.