Skip to main content
Participant
Mar 11, 2008 7:14 PM UTC
Question

SWF or FLV

Few things make me feel stupid but this is starting to. I have an Adobe Media Server fully configured and ready to use.

This is my question: I have both videos and tutorials. I have created my tutorials using Adobe Captive 3, videos are created from many outside sources.

My Adobe Captive and Adobe Flash Pro create only SWF files. So why do I have a Media Server? The point is that I have a large population that accesses my site daily. My site has a max capacity of 10M up and down. The SWF files are very large and I do not want the user do have to down load the whole file before viewing it. I also do not want to use bandwidth to down load a tutorial that was not fully viewed.

My media server only serves up FLV files. So what is Adobe thinking? I can convert the SWF files to FLV “not using an Adobe product”.

So to ask a stupid question: Should I be converting my SWF files to FLV? And if not why?

Thanks in advance.
From A long time web developer and database integrator feeling a little stupid.
    This topic is closed to new replies. Start a new post to keep the conversation going.

    3 replies

    Inspiring
    Oct 1, 2008 4:01 AM UTC
    On Mon, 11 Aug 2008 15:33:55 +0000 (UTC), "panej"
    <webforumsuser@macromedia.com> wrote:

    >We are in the same exact boat. While waiting for a feedback on this topic, we're looking into Connect Server for the .SWF files.

    SWF to FLV conversion can be done easily with this tool:
    MP3FLV Lossless Converter www.mp3flvconverter.com


    Translate
    Participant
    Oct 8, 2008 1:31 PM UTC
    I am feeling really lost here, I’m running though the same issue. I do have to convert SWFs or FLAs to FLVs; is there a way to do so? I find it extremely frustrating that if you develop a movie using flash, although you can export it to a Windows avi file or to a QuickTime movie, you cannot export it to an FLV… I understand that the word “Flash” from FLash Video means that you can view it via Flash player, but wouldn’t it make sense to be able to export a Flash movie to an FLV using Adobe “Creative” Suite rather than having to use some obscure software to perform the conversion?
    Translate
    Participant
    Aug 11, 2008 3:33 PM UTC
    We are in the same exact boat. While waiting for a feedback on this topic, we're looking into Connect Server for the .SWF files.
    Translate