P: Text and symbol generation in images

[Angelic_child5CF3]

I am trying to generate a logo with a desired text. It is not accepting it.

[Anubhav M]

Hello @Raju Kumar34491061gvpj,

Sorry to hear about this experience. Would you mind sharing more details about what is not working? 

• What device, browser/version, and module are you using?
• Please include any screenshots/videos of the issue.
• If you're running into a prompt issue, please share the prompts you're using. 

Also, check out our Firefly issues and error page here: (https://helpx.adobe.com/firefly/kb/limitations.html).

Looking forward to hearing from you.

Thanks,

Anubhav

[Ira349188077b28]

The text in images generated is not in english.  

[jane-e]

@Ira349188077b28 

Adobe Firefly does not support generating text. You can use Adobe Express.

Jane

[Ira349188077b28]

The images it generates contain characters and text, which 99% of the time is not English despite the setting. 

[Monika Gause]

The images it generates contain characters and text, which 99% of the time is not English despite the setting. 

Text to image can not generate any text that makes sense. 

[Roxanne32010064fw7y]

When I type the words "No Escape" it shows up in some other language.

[droopydog500]

Can you please show an image of what you are referring to? Thanks.

[jane-e]

@Roxanne32010064fw7y 

Firefly cannot generate text (yet). Adobe is aware of this issue. You can bring it into Adobe Express for the text.

Jane

[Roxanne32010064fw7y]

Thanks

[Rosane35216144s9ty]

Ele não gera textos, falei pra ele gerar um texto e ele gerou um cara com cabeça de tigre, um de aguia e varias paisagens nada aver

[droopydog500]

Please share the prompt you used and the resulting image for us to help you better. Thank you.

[Corinna35129583ycdw]

Hallo,
Ich schätze hier wurde Stil mit Stift verwechselt! Hahaha

[viatonx]

Hello. We get unsuccessful results when we want anything to be written on objects.
We are looking forward to more realistic and accurate results.

[PMJorg]

Every time, with no exceptions, when I ask Adobe Firefly to create 3D lettering on a gallery wall that spells out a phrase, I get this:

Here is my prompt: 

white 3D lettering on a white wall, lighted with spot lights from above and the left side that says (spell each word exactly like I wrote it in between " and "): "Reality as we see it" and "is a hallucination created by our brain" in two lines

Why is this? AI is highly trained on text, and knows how to spell.

[droopydog500]

While it has gotten better, Firefly (and most other AI image generators) is not good at putting exact text from a prompt into an image. Sometimes it is perfect, but usually, it does not get it right.  The best solution is to use Adobe Express or Photoshop to add text in.  The more complicated the angle or perspective of the text, the more likely you will need Photoshop to get what you want.

[PMJorg]

Maybe Firefly suffers from the same oversight or blind-sight as new artists and designers. When focusing most of its energy into  how something looks, rather than splitting the attention to detail between the visual and the content, it makes errors due to inattentiveness. Learning a  healthy balance between appearance and content takes effort at first, but eventually good designers learn it and rarely make this kind of mistake as they go forward. Firefly needs to use both eyes, with one on appearance, the other on content. 

[rayek.elfin]

GenAI is not intelligent: the algorithm doesn't actually understand what it is doing. The term "Artificial Intelligence" is a misnomer, and popularized, but there is no awareness there. It's not even 'stupid'. It is merely an algorithm and can't even create true random numbers (hence: the seed).

Comparing Firefly with a real human intelligent designer is like comparing a rock with a planet that has a vibrant natural ecosystem.

[DawnAble]

AI image diffusion models can be trained on text. Unfortunately, Adobe's Firefly models are not. I hope they rectify this soon. 

In the meantime, DALL-E 3 and Midjourney v6 will.  

[PMJorg]

Thank you for that information. I've noticed ChatGPT is no better at it. I'll have to try the other two!

Get Outlook for Android<>

[@mj]

Hi,

I won't sugarcoat it. Firefly is terrible at text.

I am aware this is on the product teams radar.

When the fix will come is not known.

Best

mj

iMSD

[briced40890199]

Je demande de générer une image où il y a écrit "Bon anniversaire" (en Français) et il me génère des images où il y a écrit "Happy birthday" (en anglais), ce qui est totalement stupide car je suis Français. Il va falloir apprendre à programmer...

[Anonymous37037930cx5u]

It is not able to generate correct text in images using the prompt.

[droopydog500 · Accepted solution]

@Anonymous37037930cx5u, While it has gotten better, Firefly (and most other AI image generators) is not good at putting exact text from a prompt into an image. Sometimes it is perfect, but usually, it does not get it right.  The best solution is to use Adobe Express or Photoshop to add text in.  The more complicated the angle or perspective of the text, the more likely you will need Photoshop to get what you want.

Please see this article on why generating text in AI image generators is hard:

https://theconversation.com/if-ai-image-generators-are-so-smart-why-do-they-struggle-to-write-and-co...

[Ahmet38651091lb88]

I needed an image with the word PARK on it to use in my game, but the application could not do this. He put trees around and the text was very small, and when he said give without trees, the same thing happened again. In another parking article, when I added it to my game, the image remained horizontal and did not work for me.

[Kartika Rawat]

Hi Ahmet38651091lb88!

Sorry about the trouble. Can you share what prompt you're using? Also, please post a screenshot that shows the issue. 

Let us know.

Thanks,

KR

moved to discussions.