P: Generative Remove Feedback (Lr Classic & Lr Eco)

This feature feels like useless these days… I am trying to remove a light source (light bulb) in the background and this does not do anything other than changing the shape of the light a bit, not even trying to remove the light/bulb.

Not able to attach a screenshot here.

Also in photoshop, when I try to remove a similar object, it degrades quality of the whole photo

Fingers need work

I have to remove studio lights and soft boxes from images with black backgrounds. Instead of removing the light, it just replaces it with another beam of light. I feel like with the solid black background it should just match that and make it all black but it tries to generate something new.

in last week I noticed aboslutely terrible degradation of generative remove tool in LR…….does ugly results…...this didnt happened before! What is the reason? 

I find that the detect objects is very poor.  Im trying for example to remove a white rope across some dark water and rocks.  Whatever I try it cannot detect the rope just a very broad area

please create an option for generative reomve where it ONLY removes and does not attempt to replace what you’re trying to remove with a poorly rendered version of the same thing. If I’m trying to remove the reflection of a four sided softbox it’s not because I wanted an 8 sided softbox in it’s place… 

After changing perspective corrections, the patch cannot be used correctly; it appears in a different location.

In future Lightroom updates, please add a feature to the Generative Fill tool that allows a generated element to be replicated across multiple photos—ensuring the generated section is identical across a series of similar shots—or add the ability to use a detail from another photo as a reference "patch" to guide the generation process.

It is missing to say what it should replace. For example i selected a mouth from a guest because he had his tongue out for some reason. AI analyzed it and created pictures with a tongue and a mouth but as i could not say “remove mouth”. I had multiple situation where it was just bad and i thought at this time, where AI is so good now, Lightroom just keeps to getting worse. It gives competitors big advantages. For Example Imagen offers really good AI Editing. When does it come to Lightroom?

I am finding that the remove AI generative options cannot properly remove a powerline from and image with a cloudy background.  None of the 3 generative options successfully removes the wire. Each option only lightens the wire.