Copy link to clipboard
Copied
The recommended order for applying edits is:
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
I ahve tried several times to remove people from an image only nto have generative remove generate altered images of the people instead of removing. I did this on a cropped photo.
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
Remove first, crop later. If some of the person is hidden by the crop, Gen AI tries to rebuild based on those cropped pixels.
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
Genarative Füllung und Objektivunschärfe funtionieren bei mir nicht....LR 13.3
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
good start but sometimes it adds elements as opposed to removing them . For example, i wanted to remove a man and a woman from a photo as thr subject was huge tree instead of removing the couple teh AI engine replaced them with a dog ...Even the variations contained animals ...if we could have a prompt like PS that would be great...
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
As has been mentioned above and included within the FAQ (link shared in first post at top of thread); you must select the entire component to be removed. This includes shadows, etc. It's also important that you apply any crop after using Generative Remove otherwise the area not visible to you may still have an influence the final result.
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
I often use generative AI in Photoshop to fill the edges of panoramic pictures, I stitched in Lightroom.
So for test reasons of the new feature, I took a complex sample with a floor and high ISO. But it's still the same as before: Lightroom does not reconize the "empty" edges as part of the image.
So, I still have to switch to Photoshop where this is no issue...
p.s. btw: I often asked for an update on the panorama stitcher. I miss a function to move the centre of the picture, like you can do in 20 years old PTgui. Hope, that AI can help here soon, too?
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
Really good step into right direction 🙂
But with beta, performance is still bad. marking the area/object that should be filled is veery sloow.
Hope, this will be improved 😉
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
I'm still testing it. The idea is simply brilliant. Thank you.
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
Really awesome feature!! I am working in real estate and in Lightroom i merge to hdr and i edit my pictures. I am still waiting Sky Replacement directly in Lightroom Classic, you do not have idea how much time i loose opening each photo in Photoshop to add sky replacement. Please come with a sky replacement and AI based sharpness, is much better than normal sharpness.
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
Hi.
While trying to apply thge generative remove tool when i click "Apply" after the selection it always returns the error "Generative Remove Failed". The service is not responding. Please check your internet and try again"
I have tried to add Lightroom to the Firewall options and even deactivated the firewall to try.
Can someone help me?
Best regards from Portugal
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
For some reason, after this update I can't move the source selection of my healing/cloning brush tool, so when I don't use the AI option, just the "old" brush. Normally, you had a tiny button in every circle or shape and you could move them to anywhere: either the source or the destination. Now I can only move the destination around. I hope this isn't a bug and I disabled something by accident. It's driving me crazy. If I want to adjust it, I need to delete the current brush circle and draw a new one, no matter how little I want to move it. It's insane.
Can someone confirm this? Should I report this as a bug?
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
Same here. Very infuriating and disruipting my workflow 😞
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
CREATED A PHANTOM IMAGE - INSTEAD OF THE PERSON WHO WAS REMOVED. REMOVED AN ADULT REPLACED IT WITH A CHILD NOT ORIGINALLY IN THE IMAGE
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
Experimenting a bit more - very exciting. However, "Synch Settings >> Remove" doesn't seem to work. Across multiple sets of bracketed frames, it says "Lightroom Classic. Skipped x Generative Remove spots" (where x = # of selected frames - 1)
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
The explantion as to how you can copy/paste/sync, etc is given in https://helpx.adobe.com/lightroom-cc/using/generative-remove-faq.html
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
Hey Ian, great to hear from you - hope you're well! I looked at the link above, and I must be blind, but I don't see anything about sync settings(?)
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
Clicking deeper, I did find https://helpx.adobe.com/lightroom-cc/using/generative-remove-faq.html#best-practices about copy/paste. I tried again with copy/paste (instead of Synch) and still get the "skipped" modal dialog box. Based on your suggestion, I then did look at develop and saw the "Update All" button - so I guess it did actually try to copy, but didn't auto-update. WISH 1: Change confusing modal dialog which looks like nothing happened. WISH 2: enable auto-update esp. with bracketed shots, would hope for an identical "removal" so that Focus Stacking and/or Pano Stitching will still work. WISH 2b: if can't do auto-update, then provide "update all" function to avoid going frame by frame and having to manually do so. For a beta release though, looking promising!
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
I was watching some youtube videos about the latest release that includes the generative AI remove feature, and it was mentioned that once it gets promoted out of early access it will require monthly credits to use.
Does this mean, on top of the subscription price I already pay for the 2tb photography plan, I'll have to pay additional to use this feature?
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
At the moment, it's all still being figured out, so we don't know details. What we can say is credits are already included in your plan (the amount varies by plan), and if you go beyond those credits, it'll still work but slower, even if you don't buy more credits. At the moment, there is no speed penalty even if you use up all your credits.
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
Let's leave it alone ... a long way to go
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
Why does a “REMOVE TOOL” persist in creating objects, when we want to use it to DELETE them? Explanation: I want to delete a person in the background, who is in front of some foliage. The tool does delete this person, but replaces him with someone else? I feel like I'm being trolled by the software.
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
It appears that the Remove tool is ruined! I can no longer fine tune the placement of the sample area. Is this really the case or am I missing something?
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
I have the same problem, see a coupl of comments back. It's driving me crazy. But weirdly nobody else is taking about it.