Copy link to clipboard
Copied
The recommended order for applying edits is:
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
The behaviour you describe regarding an image that you susbsequently denoise is expected. The order edits should be Denoise - Heal (Including Gen Remove) - Crop/Edit - AI Selective edits
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
I will try that Ian. My preference has always been to get everything right and denoise last 🤷:male_sign:
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
The tool works mostly good - for me the white line when starting to mark the area which should be removed is not very good (too bold) - would like to have the colored field of the pencil so the borders are much more better to see.
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
Tolle Erleichterung, ht bei mir überwiegend sehr gut funktioniert. Die Wartezeit ist akzeptabel!
Gruß
Andreas
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
Wonderful., It is not a remove tool, It replaces the object with something replicating the environment. This is a feature that I was really looking forward for. Very useful.
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
Rikk,
It's amazing. It's amazing. It's amazing. So happy this is in lightroom classic now, saving me from going to PS. Does a great job for me.
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
You need to ensure that the connected shadows are removed otherwise the model will put something in to cause the shadow. I've attached a screenshot of your image with the selection/mask shown and pole gone.
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
Handy tool, I'm glad you've added this into Lightroom Classic instead of having to open photoshop for each of these edits. I would recommend "subtract" being the default option rather than add.
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
please disregard my last post, I used your feature wrong lol whats there is working great
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
Very usefull, but if the object in some big it doesn't remove just remplace. Waiting the final version looking foward for it.
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
I love this but it crashes now 100% of the time I use "Remove" with Generative AI unchecked - so now I can ONLY use Generative AI.
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
Very disappointed. I was hoping it would save me going into Photoshop to use the remove tool there which is excellent and gives me what I want 95% of the time on the first go. I have tried to get rid of an overhanging branch using the new AI remove tool 17 times now and the branch or parts of it are still there.
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
Marche tres bien pour remplacer, mais je n'arrive pas a supprimer une personne ou un objet d'une photo, j'ai pourtant utilise toutes les options ...
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
After a little bit of practice time I used this tool very often (let´s say 80% !) directly in LRc instead of switching to PS. What I would like to have changed in the final version is to use only the "red colour" for designing the mask instead of the "white line" (it´s too bold for me - with the "red colour" like in PS or when using "improvement of the mask" it´s easier for me to get the exact mask!). Thx 4 incorporation of this tool into LRc.
Alex.
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
In my use so far the tool mostly produces excellent results. Sometimes the generated patches don't blend quite as well as I would like. Especially in those cases I love the variations feature: one is usually almost perfect.
I have run into the issue others have mentioned, when the tool stubbornly keeps replacing one unwanted object with a different one. I would be perfectly happy with a removal-only tool that replaces an unwanted object with a patch that is intelligently synthesised from the surrounding areas.
All I want to be able to do in LR is removing stuff with as little traces as possible. If I wanted to put something else there, I would resort to Photoshop where you have control over what gets placed there instead.
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
After the introduction of the generative AI non of the spot removal tools work well anymore. They don't really remove spots or other small deistractions (sensor dust, straws of gras in the foreground, short plane tracks in the night sky) anymore, only making them a little less visible. They are alwys still visible afterwards, just a little less visible. Doesen't matter ehich tool I choose and aöso generative AI doesen't do a better job.
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
Your description suggests that you've applied the Generative AI, Clone, Heal tools to an image with an AI mask. You can easily check whether this is the case or not by looking for a red dot below the Masks icon on the toolbar. If red dot is present, then you'll need to 'Update the AI Mask'. See atatched screenshot.
To avoid the same issue in future, it's best to apply the Remove tool before creating an AI mask.
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
Thanks for your suggestion. I was indeed using AI maks. But updating them made no change. So I completely reset an image and tried again. Still got the problem as you can see in the screenshots.
That's the original image:
With the normal remove tool:
With the AI remove tool:
With the healing tool:
With the clone tool:
As I wrote, other things like sensor dust, hot pixels, airplane tracks, ... suffer from the same issue.
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
Thanks for your reply. My problem is, that all remove tools don't work properly anymore. They all don't remove objekcts correctly anymore and only kind of tone them down. This even happens also for small areas like hot pixels.
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
@kernto Check the Opacity slider for each of your repairs. It sounds like it's turned down, whereas it should be at 100 for complete removal.
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
Thanks a lot for your help, I guess that was the solution.
I guess I should have nitced that myself😅
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
Adjacent photos shot in burst. I removed 2 people, 1 van, copped final. Generative remove worked well, except for the slogan on the wall about South Africa for a free Palestine. The parts of the slogan got mashed into something unreadable, so that necessitated more cropping than I had originally wanted to do.