Copy link to clipboard
Copied
The recommended order for applying edits is:
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
Hello,
Just started to play with the Lightroom Classic updates. Like Photoshop, I would like to be able to see the generated variations without having to toggle thru them.
Thanks
Stu
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
Very happy to see this tool in LR Classic! Unfortunately my first experience was not too good. I tried to remove an orange snack bag from a table scene, and no matter how many times I refreshed, it continued to give me different orange objects in place of the snack bag. I never got a variation which just showed the table with the bag removed, which is what I would hope a remove or erase tool would do. When using a tool to remove a distraction, I always want the distraction gone, not replaced with a different distraction. If I want something different, I'll go to Photoshop and type in what I want. It would be great if the remove feature focused on removing things.
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
@NicoleYM That sounds like you aren't selecting the bag's cast shadow also. Is that possible?
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
This tool is quite amazing... not perfect but amazing. I have run into issues when using the tool to remove power lines with a blue sky background. But all in all a very welcome addition to Lightroom.
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
The replacement is very visible if tonal adjustments have already been made to the image ....... why can't the tonal adjustments also be applied to the patched area (or make that an option)? The content of the replacement is good, but because the lighting is different, it is very visible.
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
It's not what it appears to be. It's too long, and many times it doesn't work, so no, it's too bad.
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
Bonjour, mes premiers essais sont désastreux. Probablement que je l'utilise mal J'ai tenté de supprimer une tasse clairement définie sur l'image et il l'a remplacé par je ne sais trop quoi, peut-être une partie du gâteau situé juste à côté. J'ai aussi tenté de supprimer un petit bocal et au lieu de le supprimer, il l'a remplacé par une autre tasse probablement trouvée dans une photo trouvé par IA. Je continue mon expériementation.
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
Mes 2e essais sont presques pires. Je demande de supprimer un objet très bien défini dans la photo et il remplace l'objet par autre chose que IA semble avoir puisé dans ses photos alors que ce que je lui demande c'est de supprimer l'objet tracé au masque avec le pinceau. ??? Des conseils SVP
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
@photo2703 Make sure you are selecting cast shadows of the object you are removing, as well as reflections, and any discontinuous pieces.
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
Rebonjour, j'ai visionné des vidéos sur Youtube et j'ai remarqué que l'outil IA générative fonctionne bien sur de plus petits objets. Les premiers essais que j'ai faits portaient sur des objets qui prenaient plus de place dans l'image (environ 15-20%). Je viens d'essayer sur de plus petits objets et ça fonctionne bien. Ne pas oublier de mettre l'opacité à 100%. J'ai vu aussi un vidéo dans lequel la personne voulait supprimer la personne avec en arrière-plan un mur de briques et l'outil IA, au lieu supprimer la personne et la remplacer par des briques rouges, il changeait la personne par une autre personne alors que ce n'était vraiment pas le but qu'il recherchait.
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
It´s not what it appears to be.It´s too slowly,and many times it doesn´t work,so no,it´s too bad.
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
God results with Generative Remove for removing 3/ 4 of the background , I have used the 5th variant- almoe perfect.
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
does not remove objects - only transform them a bit
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
It is a really great feature. I just have one comment. For professional photographers like me, who apreciate every detail; the resolution of the generated pixels is insuficient. Maybe, you could improve the resolution of the generative AI, because with high megapixel cameras, it could be seen a little bit fake or bad editted.
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
The idea is great but the processing time is sooooo looong it makes me not want to use it 😞
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
This is frankly quite dispointing, not nearly as good as the same feature in photoshop. This is most surprising as I would have expected adode could have used the same AI feature/algorithms as in photoshop instead of seamly starting from scratch.
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
The generative removal of LRc was great, I tested it and it was perfect.
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
This is working really well for me in Lightroom Classic on my Mac. However, the edits only appear when I export to JPG, not to DNG.
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
hi,
this tool doesnt work on my computer. Tells me to check my internet connection!!!!!!!!!
rgds
Hallgeir
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
Overall it worked well but. I erased a chainlink fence and sign in the lower left of this picture. However, there is a little bit of a tone difference just above the level of the water where they were removed that can be seen. Also didn't do so well removing a chain link fence in the same spot.
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
In situations where I want to remove "tourists" from a shot, most of the time, it just replaces the person I am trying to remove with another person or object, rather than simply removing it and generating a similar background. I would say 1 out of 10 times it simply removes the person. The rest of the time, it replaces the person with another very badly rendered one. Since it is labled a remove tool, this is disappointing. Seems like the default should be to just remove the person or object. Adding a new random person or object is not needed in LR.
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
This is working very well for me, I am saving time when making edits by not having to go to Photoshop to remove distractions in some of my images! It also serves the purpose of teaching me to look for distractions when taking the photo by making me more aware.
Copy link to clipboard
Copied
Great Start. It takes a while for Generative Remove to remove a few spots - so I chose the regular remove tool instead, but it crashed 4 times in a row.