Wechsel von LR 5 zu LRC - die meisten Entwicklungseinstellungen verschwunden

[epictures]

Hallo zusammen

Ich bin nun endlich von LR 5 auf LRC umgestiegen. Meinen bestehenden LR 5-Katalog habe ich problemlos auf LRC aktualisieren können und alle Bilder sind vorhanden.

Dann ist mir jedoch aufgefallen, dass die Entwicklungseinstellungen bei den meisten Bildern verschwunden sind. Farbe, Kontrast, Ausschnitt usw. fehlen praktisch überall. Nur bei einzelnen Bildern wurden die Einstellungen übernommen.

Hat jemand eine Idee, woran das liegt?

[F. McLion]

Es dürfte schwierig sein, jemand mit denselben Erfahrungen zu finden, da die meisten wahrscheinlich schon lange auf einer neueren Version waren. Abhilfe wird es vermutlich auch keine geben, vielleicht war der Sprung der Versionen zu weit.

Was ist der Unterschied zwischen denen, die funktioniert haben und denen die nicht funktioniert haben?

Prozessversion, Quelle, Dateiformat ... ?

Wenn du Lr5 noch installiert hast, kannst du, wenn du was herausfindest, das eventuell vorher noch aktualisieren und dann das Upgrade des Katalogs nochmal machen.

[epictures]

Danke F. McLion

Leider habe ich LR5 nicht mehr installiert, da ich den entsprechenden PC neu aufsetzen musste. 

Ich werde versuchen, herauszufinden, ob es eine Regelmässigkeit bei den funktionierenden und nicht funktionierenden Bildern gibt.

[GoldingD]

Please post in a reply a full screen capture of one of your LrC Develop Module screen with one of these poorly behaving photos selected. Note that the History Panel may be important to see, and the Navigation Panel, the Histogram, and the Basic Panel, and as very very old Lr is involved in pat editing, the Collaboration Panel.

Example:

[epictures]

Hi GoldingD

Thank you for your reply. I attached the requested screenshot. It contains everything but the Collaboration Panel which I didn't find. 

I have a developed TIF from the regarding CR2 wich contains many development settings and also objectiv calibrations. I'm sure that these changes where saved in the CR2 in LR5. But now there is only the import step available in History...

[epictures]

Sorry. Here is the screenshot

[dj_paige]

Your history panel says you Imported the photo. Importing is not the way to upgrade a catalog, and is the reason that you see items missing. The proper way to upgrade the catalog is to take the Lr 5 catalog and open it in LrC 14.

Translation to English

I have a developed TIF from the regarding CR2 wich contains many development settings and also objectiv calibrations. I'm sure that these changes where saved in the CR2 in LR5.

This is incorrect, Lightroom 5 edits are never saved in the CR2 file. Your edits are saved in the Lr 5 catalog, which is why you must upgrade that catalog to an LrC 14 catalog.

[epictures]

But the import is dated to April 2016. I opened the catalog with LrC 14 and was prompted to upgrade it.

[dj_paige]

Okay, so the import was in 2016, but then there were no edits applied.

Maybe you have accidentally upgraded the wrong catalog file.

[epictures]

I tested many backuped catalogs back to 2018. All are the same. I'm sure that back then the development settings where definitly included. But I only find development settings for some fotos. Is it possible that this issue is caused by unrecognized objectiv profiles? Because it seems to me that pictures made with my Tamron or Sigma Objectivs and also with a Canon 17-55 contain development settings but images made with my Canon 70-200 and 400 (with or without converters) don't have any development settings anymore...

[dj_paige]

If there are no edits in the catalog file, as shown in the History Panel, then the photo was never edited.

Sometimes we see people accidentally import photos twice (and don't even realize that they have imported it twice), one version of the photo is edited, the other version is not edited. You need to search for this in Lightroom Classic. Follow all four of these steps in order:

1. In the Lightroom Classic Library Module, on the left, under Catalog, click on All Photographs
2. Turn off all filters (Ctrl-L once or twice)
3. Turn off all stacking (Photo->Stacking->Expand All Stacks)
4. Search for at least one of these photos by file name using the Lightroom Classic Filter Bar

Let us know if you find two copies of the photo via this search.

[epictures]

Thanks. I searched for the file name as you wrote. The only duplicate I find is the developed copy as TIF. There are no duplicates regarding the CR2 originals. I think I have to live with this...