Aesthetic or Commercial Appeal of Image

[somsakk20652]

Hello,

I got "Aesthetic or Commercial Appeal of Image"

"Thanks for giving us the chance to consider your image. Unfortunately, during our review we found that it doesn't have the aesthetic or commercial appeal we're looking for, so we can't accept it into our collection."

This photo is flower Why? I got it?

Best Regard,

[Szalam · Accepted solution]

It's a pretty flower, but the photo composition isn't compelling.

[WarithNiallah]

I find you and your whole team [inappropriate remark] and very subjective only wanting a certain look for your catalog.  With other catalogs out there, I am proud to say we are done with you.

[Szalam]

WarithNiallah  wrote

I find you and your whole team [inappropriate remark] and very subjective only wanting a certain look for your catalog.  With other catalogs out there, I am proud to say we are done with you.

Um, I don't work for Adobe. I am just a user like you. So this isn't MY catalog at all.

[Janos Thanatos]

Playing the race card in this manner makes you look unreasonable and it diminishes the suffering of people who are actually being oppressed. Every time this objection is misused, it's taken a little less seriously and, when alerted to a case of legitimate injustice, society may one day just roll its eyes.

[daniellei4510]

You are responding to a 7 year old thread that apparently is now lacking any context, as it began by someone merely asking for an opinion as to why their flower image was rejected.

[Janos Thanatos]

Thanks for pointing that out, I hadn't noticed. Seven years is a long time for someone's ill-advised race-bating to remain on-line without someone having yet called it out. I hope it's still there in seven more years, and my response along with it. Calling the "legend" Szalam a racist because he gave a luke-warm crituqe to her composition was intolerable and people ought to appreciate that consequences endure, don't you think? . I guess Adobe will decide how long it stays there, and when it's no longer worth commenting on. But, as for the context, need I remind you, "il n'y a pas de hors-texte"?

[Abambo]

@Janos Thanatos ,

I've locked this thread now, so nobody can answer anymore, until unlocked.

@WarithNiallah is not the OP of this threat and had or has a personal grudge with Adobe and @Szalam. I've checked his account, his last post was from 2017. A repeated post like the above would have been a reason to report this user. You can do so by hitting the report link.Reporting for 6 years old posts however makes no sense.

Thanks for standing up and defending the people's rights! You're welcome to denounce such behaviour in the future, either by publicly posting, like here or by sending a PM to a forum moderator or by reporting the post, where an Adobe employee will follow-up.