Before and after image previously rejected

[storm_42]

So an image of mine (ai generated) was rejected. I posted on the community page to get feedback on why it was rejected. I worked on the image again, and hope that i got it better this time, would just like feedback on the re-edit and if i am headed in the right direction, or am out of my depth with this project.

[daniellei4510]

The edges still seem a little soft at 100%. Could you upload one without the background removed? I'd like to try something with it. That said, though, I'm never sure where Adobe draws the line when it comes to cartoon illustrations.

[storm_42]

Sure, I have attached the original image here.

[daniellei4510]

Thank you, I'll experiment with it.

[daniellei4510]

I'd say it's a bit of a toss up between the released version of Photoshop and the beta. And neither in my opinion would be accepted. The issue is the object itself not having any well-defined edges. They are too rough to start with. While the background can be removed, the process can't fix the poorly rendered edges.

[Abambo]

You have cutout issues, but this is a 100% refusal: 

[storm_42]

Oh wow, i didnt even notice that line, thank you. Will definately work on the cutout.