sberic : Others must work remotely and are building workflows to support that approach. Which is exactly why almost all vendors of MAM-ish solutions have contributed their share to the "hundreds of panels out there", many of which allow for the workflow described because it is common not only nowadays but has been so for quite a few years. No need to re-invent the wheel, but choose carefully. If anyone's existing, proof-of-whatever solution is so unique, I wonder how long they can support it in the long run. If they start from scratch, they better plan to make their system so good they can sell it to others for many years, because otherwise it's not worth the effort. Everything is eventually deprecated, which we have seen over and over in the fundamental changes in the last 15-20 years of this industry. It is natural to want to respond to feedback directly within an application like this. I beg to differ from your opinion. My criterion for differentiation is this: If someone needs to edit clip-related metadata which shall afterwards be available for all users accessing the associated media files, using Premiere as primary frontend might be an approach of little use, because you can have that cheaper and more reliable in a browser. This is the scenario funkelodeon​ has described (my guess based on the use of "clips" instead of "edits" or "sequences"). The probable limitation not mentioned could be, for instance, they do not want to use proxies but need to look at the original hi-res and/or they need to output to a (broadcast) video monitor. Now, if the need is to review sequences, this boils down to the same thing because even though there are MAMs which can represent a Premiere sequence exactly as you have it in the app, they currently have no means of rendering effects and advanced transitions in the browser (or on the server and then stream it to the browser), which is why the editor will have to render the sequence to a clip. Sidenote: Yes, Adobe provides the GCD, which is why I would prefer they start fixing issues which are (not only) IMHO more important, instead of blaming it on, for example, the video card vendors. It is a foundation, and yet sturdiness is what I'm still waiting for (quality is an individual definition, that's okay, but there is something like "professional/industry standard", which ... I will stop here because continuing would quickly be off topic, and I've already discussed this with Bruce Bullis​ and others from Adobe, some of them years ago, and basically we're going in circles.)
... View more