Skip to main content
Joshyi3
Known Participant
Nov 15, 2026 2:01 PM UTC
Open for Voting

Generative Remove fails when removing a bra strap but works elsewhere in the same photo

Issue: Generative Remove fails specifically when removing a visible bra strap

I am a photographer experiencing a recurring problem with Lightroom Classic's AI Generative Remove feature.

While editing a client's photograph, I attempted to remove a visible bra strap, which is a routine portrait-retouching adjustment.

However, Lightroom repeatedly displays the following error:

"Generative Remove Failed. We encountered an issue with your results. Please view our guidelines and try again."

Steps to reproduce:

  1. Open the photograph in Lightroom Classic's Develop module.

  2. Activate the Remove tool and enable Generative AI.

  3. Select the visible bra strap for removal.

  4. Attempt to generate the removal.

  5. Lightroom returns the error message instead of generating a result.

Additional testing:

To investigate the issue, I tested Generative Remove on a completely different area of the exact same photograph.

The tool worked successfully without any errors.

However, when I returned to the bra strap and attempted the removal again, the same error appeared.

This suggests that the failure is specific to the selected area rather than a general connection or processing problem.

Expected behaviour:

Generative Remove should remove the bra strap and reconstruct the surrounding area naturally, just as it does with other unwanted objects.

Actual behaviour:

The generation fails, displays a message referring to Adobe's guidelines, and produces no results.

My concern:

I suspect Adobe's AI content moderation may be incorrectly interpreting an ordinary clothing strap or the surrounding skin as restricted content.

If this is the reason, I believe the system needs further refinement. Removing visible bra straps is a standard professional photography practice and does not inherently involve inappropriate content.

Furthermore, because the generation fails before displaying any variations, I cannot use the built-in Report Variation feature to report the problem directly.

I would appreciate Adobe investigating the following:

  1. Why the Generative Remove feature works elsewhere in the same photograph but consistently fails when removing the bra strap.

  2. Whether AI content moderation is responsible for rejecting the operation.

  3. Whether Adobe can improve how the tool handles legitimate clothing and portrait-retouching adjustments.

  4. Whether a reporting option can be made available when generation fails before producing results.

I have included a screenshot of the error message.

Thank you for investigating this issue.

Josh Boyer
Josh Boyer Photography

    1 reply

    johnrellis
    Legend
    Nov 15, 2026 10:51 PM UTC

    I suspect Adobe's AI content moderation may be incorrectly interpreting an ordinary clothing strap or the surrounding skin as restricted content.

     

    Indeed, many have complained about this.

     

    Adobe is deathly afraid of violating content regulations (which vary greatly across the world) and provoking political backlashes, so they’ve made their AI very risk adverse, more inclined to falsely identify something as “p o r n” rather than let true “p o r n” through. In geek speek, Adobe’s AI has a high false-positive rate for identifying adult and child p o r n (not allowed to type that nasty word in this forum).

     

    Adobe AI won’t even allow Edward Weston to edit his famous conch shell:

    https://community.adobe.com/questions-675/lightroom-classic-generative-ai-question-983446?postid=4040931#post4040931

    Translate