Generative Remove fails when removing a bra strap but works elsewhere in the same photo
Issue: Generative Remove fails specifically when removing a visible bra strap
I am a photographer experiencing a recurring problem with Lightroom Classic's AI Generative Remove feature.
While editing a client's photograph, I attempted to remove a visible bra strap, which is a routine portrait-retouching adjustment.
However, Lightroom repeatedly displays the following error:
"Generative Remove Failed. We encountered an issue with your results. Please view our guidelines and try again."
Steps to reproduce:
-
Open the photograph in Lightroom Classic's Develop module.
-
Activate the Remove tool and enable Generative AI.
-
Select the visible bra strap for removal.
-
Attempt to generate the removal.
-
Lightroom returns the error message instead of generating a result.
Additional testing:
To investigate the issue, I tested Generative Remove on a completely different area of the exact same photograph.
The tool worked successfully without any errors.
However, when I returned to the bra strap and attempted the removal again, the same error appeared.
This suggests that the failure is specific to the selected area rather than a general connection or processing problem.
Expected behaviour:
Generative Remove should remove the bra strap and reconstruct the surrounding area naturally, just as it does with other unwanted objects.
Actual behaviour:
The generation fails, displays a message referring to Adobe's guidelines, and produces no results.
My concern:
I suspect Adobe's AI content moderation may be incorrectly interpreting an ordinary clothing strap or the surrounding skin as restricted content.
If this is the reason, I believe the system needs further refinement. Removing visible bra straps is a standard professional photography practice and does not inherently involve inappropriate content.
Furthermore, because the generation fails before displaying any variations, I cannot use the built-in Report Variation feature to report the problem directly.
I would appreciate Adobe investigating the following:
-
Why the Generative Remove feature works elsewhere in the same photograph but consistently fails when removing the bra strap.
-
Whether AI content moderation is responsible for rejecting the operation.
-
Whether Adobe can improve how the tool handles legitimate clothing and portrait-retouching adjustments.
-
Whether a reporting option can be made available when generation fails before producing results.
I have included a screenshot of the error message.
Thank you for investigating this issue.
Josh Boyer
Josh Boyer Photography
