Skip to main content
Known Participant
Oct 19, 2025 5:18 PM UTC
Needs More Info

P: Compare after soft proofing shows only edited version

I think I found a bug in LrC when soft proofing.


Typically when you edit a picture and then hit the compare button, you are shown on the left the original picture and on the right the edited picture, like on the top part of the following screenshot.

But if you do soft proofing this comparison is broken, as you can see in the bottom part of the following screenshot, where I am being presented left and right with the same edited photo.


Steps to reproduce:

1- Click on soft proof
2- Click on create proof copy
3- Click on compare button  Before/After Button (Compare is a Library Feature)
4- Click on single photo to show only edited picture
5- Remove proof copy (only from LrC)
6- Click on compare > l  Before/After Button (Compare is a Library Feature)

 

Result:
L
eft edited phot and right edited photo

Expected:
Left is unedited/Right is edited


Reproduction was done on version 14.5.1 

Mod Comments in Bold

22 replies

ShootingPixelsAndy
Inspiring
Oct 20, 2025 9:17 AM UTC

Yep, it's broken. Once you've created a soft proof copy LrC gets confused about the "edited state" of the original image. Even a reset or reverting to the import history step won't convinvce LrC to show the correct before state.

Translate
Known Participant
Oct 20, 2025 10:24 AM UTC

Thx... Another bug that will take ages to be fixed 

Translate