Skip to main content
Participating Frequently
April 5, 2020

P: Importing Files into a folder with the file system date rather than metadata date?

  • April 5, 2020
  • 22 replies
  • 664 views

I had an issue with lots of repeated files and in order to fix it I wrote my own script to calculate a hash on all files and then check which are the same. This worked very well and with it I found that I have the same exact file imported into different folders...

In my setup all the files enter those folders through an import on Lightroom.

When I digged further I found out that:

1) the files have the same MD5 hash
2) they are exactly the same
3) they have the same EXIF data and it matches reality (CREATED DATE)
4) They have a different date on the filesystem
5) The file was imported to the date the file has on the filesystem

I am very surprised with this. When we move files around the file date changes but it seems that Lightroom is importing based on that and not on the METADATA inside the file.

This is happening for .JPG 

Is this normal behaviour?

I have the latest release of LR Classic 9.2

This topic has been closed for replies.

22 replies

papereirAuthor
Participating Frequently
April 5, 2020
That's not the case. I "move" files into this directory structure by importing them. They land in the wrong folder date... It's not normal and not to be expected. What's the logical behind your comment of it being normal and expected?
Inspiring
April 5, 2020
If you have multiple physical copies of files in different folders on your computer and add the to lightroom, then lightroom will import all of them - they are different files, even though they have the same hash and metadata - this is normal and to be expected.