P: (Mac) People masks selections are not as expected (Entire Screen or Square Area)

@Andreas29710925mack You are the one name-calling and finding aggression where there is none. (Aggression and frustration are very different things.) I’m not a guy, I’m not uneducated, and I find it ironic that you are lecturing me about "shouting about posting answers I do not like". Move on. I felt your response with the acreenshot unnecessary - I’m sorry if that hurt your feelings. Maybe I was extra touchy because of the frustration with the issue, maybe it was the way you worded it, maybe your tone was misconstrued - who knows. The point is that it's not nearly as deep as you are making it. I’m not going to call you names or insult your intelligence over it. I hope you have a great day and I hope none of us have reasons to need this forum again for a long time.

@michelegranja - the difference between the original incident and your rude and impolite behavoir is: the first incident affected ALL systems - not only some. So it was clear that the problem had to do with drivers from MacOS. This time only some systems were affected - others with the same system configuration were not affected at all. 

One last word: impolite and flaming guys like you destroy important communites like this one. It's about time that you improve your language to others and find a better way to communicate. We are all not here to listen to your uneducated shouting if someone posts an answer you don't like. Don't be that agressive. We have all the same rights here.

@Andreas29710925mack  We are all very aware not all systems are impacted... we don't need to hear from everyone out there getting to do their work successfully. Your advice about arrogance is laughable based on your responses - I’m not a cookie... and having been dealing with varying levels of this issue since last April, I don't appreciate you downplaying it as you have. Just more unnecessary input.

@michelegranja ... be polite and not arrogant. The reason why I posted my experience was to show, that not all systems are affected. And guess what - now you updated your system and you are a happy cookie again. 

@SweetPeaPhotog AMD Radeon 5700 Pro 8 GB

Are you using AMD graphics?

@SweetPeaPhotog I just ran the macOS update to 14.4 and PEOPLE MASKING IS WORKING!! (With all GPU enabled)

@Andreas29710925mack I'm really happy for you.   And I don't get it - Did you come here to tell us we are lying? My people masking shuts down the program. Period. Yours still working is not a solution to my problem. Thanks, though. 

Hi folks,
sorry but I don't get it -> on my 5K iMac (2020) the people masking works as designed after I installed MacOS Ventura mid of september 2023. I checked the people masking a few minutes ago and there are no bugs here (see attached pic). LR is forced to use the GPU (AMD Radeon Pro 5700XT) acceleration to max. LR Classic V13.1 / Camera Raw 16.1 / MacOS 14,3

But telling someone that spent 5k on a computer in 2020 that they should just upgrade is insane. That's like telling someone to buy a whole new car when the battery dies. We shouldn't be forced to upgrade just to use a program we already pay for.