Skip to main content
Inspiring
Jun 18, 2011 11:12 PM UTC
Released

P: Publish to Hard Drive in Format Original does not create XMP Sidecars (LR 3.4.1)

LR 3.4.1, Win7 64-Bit:
Publish to Hard Drive in Format "Original" no longer creates XMP sidecar files along with the published originals.

Steps to reproduce:

  •  
  • Create new Catalog
  •  
  • Automatically write Changes into XMP not checked
  •  
  • Import some .cr2 files
  •  
  • Export .cr2 images in format "Original" to an export folder
  •  
  • Create Published Collection, using format "Original" to a publish folder
  •  
  • Drag a couple of images into the Published Collection
  •  
  • Publish the collection
  •  



Actual Result:

  •  
  • Images exported as originals show up with .cr2 and XMP sidecar files in export folder
  •  
  • Images published as originals show up with only .cr2 files (no XMP sidecar files) in published folder
  •  



Expected Result:

  •  
  • Images published as originals should show up with .cr2 and XMP sidecar files in published folder
  •  



The same procedure in LR 3.3 produces Raw and XMP files in both export and published folders.

As I don't have LR 3.4 installed anymore, I cannot try with LR 3.4, but maybe somebody who still has it installed can.

Beat

This topic is closed to new replies. Start a new post to keep the conversation going.

6 replies

Legend
Mar 24, 2017 3:42 PM UTC
This issue is solved in Lightroom 3.5 and later.
Translate
Inspiring
Jul 17, 2011 6:13 PM UTC
Thanks, Ben.
Translate
B+Warde
Adobe Employee
Adobe Employee
Jul 14, 2011 9:21 PM UTC
Hi Beat,

I have verified this issue and entered it in our bug database.

Thanks,
Ben
Translate
Inspiring
Jun 19, 2011 11:59 AM UTC
Thanks for checking, Jim. It would have worried me if the problem was introduced with 3.4.1 vs. 3.4.

Beat
Translate
Inspiring
Jun 19, 2011 7:01 AM UTC
Confirmed same behaviour on 3.4 on Win7 64 bit, i.e. no sidecars when publishing CR2 to HD as 'original'.
Translate
Geoff the kiwi
Community Expert
Community Expert
Jun 18, 2011 11:24 PM UTC
Beat, same on Mac with 3.4.1.
Export as Original from Export Menu includes xmp sidecar.
Publish to HD as original does not include xmp sidecar.
Would think they should have the same result.
Translate