Participant

P: Generated images violate user guidelines

Forum|Forum|2 years ago
May 23, 2023
1084 replies
306880 views

So as you can see, it's a PG-13 relatively inoffensive image of a woman in a bunny outfit. The top worked fine, and I was able to complete the top ear, which is cool. When I tried to extend the bottom with generative fill, though, I got this warning. They're just a pair of legs wearing stockings, and I wanted to extend it.

It feels like a false flag - though I could be wrong? I find myself thinking it would do the same for women in swimsuits.

Figured I'd share here.

Show previous replies

C

CAVelarde

Participating Frequently

The term "balerina en pointe" gives me the message that it violates guidelines. I tried several different canvas sizes and proportions with the same result.

Donkeet

Participant

Well you're not paying a premium for this because it is still in beta...

bradleyalphabet

Participant

They need to remove the training wheels. Not paying a premium for Adobe to dictate what art is acceptable. I'm trying to clean up a basic head-and-shoulders portrait and it's being flagged, wtaf.

N

neart45822646

Participant

Wenn man bei Generative Fill den Text-Prompt "remove moire" eingibt - um zu testen, ob PS vielleicht schon in der Lage ist, ein solches Kommando zu verstehen, wird das mit folgender Warnmeldung quittiert: "The generated images were removed because they violate user guidelines". Dies ist offensichtlich ein Fehler und nicht zutreffend. Es wäre mir jedenfalls neu, dass der Moiré-Effekt irgendetwas Anstößiges oder die Guidelines Verletzendes bedeuten könnte – auch wenn man das semantische Umfeld und Fehldeutungen in Betracht zieht.
Wichtig:
Es wäre gut, in solchen und ähnlichen Fällen eine Korrektur- oder Einspruchs-Funktion zu implementieren!

Und da Verletzungen der Guidelines potenziell mit juristischen Konsequenzen für den Nutzer verbunden sind, ist es unbedingt nötig, dem Nutzer mitzuteilen, worin in den Augen der AI der Verstoß besteht. Stichwort Explainable AI.

Anbei ein Screenshot des Bugs.

[PS Beta Version: 24.7 m2223, MacOS 13.4.1, App&System-Sprache ist Englisch]

Donkeet

Participant

I get a ton of those banners for completely innocuous prompts. Given that it is being beta tested, I'm sure the team is working on fixing these kinks.

Blondinko

Participant

@Pete.Green does your team still need more examples of non relevant warnings about guidelines violation? I get dozens of them every day, for nothing, when trying to generate some blurry backgrounds on my macro shots. I will be more than happy to provide examples if it will help to improve the tool. The generative fill is extremely needed and welcomed in macro photography and currently it is really painful and frustrating to use it and to get this warning in 90% of cases.

D

Dan The Photo Man

Inspiring

Most of my generative fills do not work because I get a violation warning...for no reason. When the beta first came out they were rare, but now they are frequent. If you need samples, I will be happy to start taking screen shots.

A

Allyson28931650l8kq

Participant

Same problem for me. Just started using Photoshop as a photo newbie this week and hve been trying to expand a photo of my 12 year old fully clothed son sitting on steps (I unfortunately croppped the side of his leg and part of his shoe out of the original shot). It would not let me add either his shoe or his knee. Don't think I am savy enough yet to figure out how to send you the file.

F

Filipa30799236ka4a

Participant

i just made a simple selection on the background of a studio picture, tried to generate a ball, and the pop up appeared about not respecting guidelines ....

it also appeared before updating.

what could be wrong?