Skip to main content
H
Hematita
Participant
May 23, 2023

P: Generated images violate user guidelines

 

So as you can see, it's a PG-13 relatively inoffensive image of a woman in a bunny outfit. The top worked fine, and I was able to complete the top ear, which is cool. When I tried to extend the bottom with generative fill, though, I got this warning. They're just a pair of legs wearing stockings, and I wanted to extend it.

It feels like a false flag - though I could be wrong? I find myself thinking it would do the same for women in swimsuits.

Figured I'd share here.

    This topic has been closed for replies.

    1087 replies

    Show previous replies
    Fine Art P
    Fine Art P
    Inspiring
    June 20, 2023

    So Adobe is now policing what we can generate with software we've purchased? As a photographer working with the nude figure, I would need to switch to another provider. What is the context of this censorship? I can see censoring images uploaded to Adobe's site for public view, but thell me Adobe isn't planning to monitor and make moral jugements about what we make on our own machines? 

      B
      Bob5E9A
      Participating Frequently
      June 20, 2023

      If gen fil can not generate a decent fill you get this notice.

        gina238
        gina238
        Inspiring
        June 20, 2023

        Just to be clear when I started this feed I saw a glitch in the generated fill tool. I am not against restrictions.  AI needs restrictions. Adobe has every right to decide to restrict copyright issues and offensive AI.  I just want to help it work better.  That's me. So save your time and don't send me petitions. 

          gina238
          gina238
          Inspiring
          June 19, 2023

          Sorry I intended to upload the psd file with saved selection. Since I made 6 different selections I honestly cant remember  which selection I  had the issue with now. I used healing brush to fix it. However I will upload a photo with circles around the areas that was an issue. One of the circles didnt work but the others did. There were people leaning over the edges and removed them all. The other five areas worked perfectly. 

            Kevin Stohlmeyer
            Community Expert
            Kevin StohlmeyerCommunity Expert
            Community Expert
            June 19, 2023

            Hi @rb16826567 did you enter any prompts when trying to remove?

              R
              robertp90358595
              Known Participant
              June 21, 2023

              What is going on with the constant community violations when trying to gen fill? This is happening a lot on very obscure things. Currently it is happening when trying to fill a spot on a wall as shown here

              I have tried various selection shapes and tried using words like wall or nothing and it always fails. This is just one example, but there have been many over the past couple weeks. I can of course reomove this manually, but what is the issue?

              Is it because the system thinks it is a bodypart or something? I mean what is it about some of these fills that no matter what is done does not seem to get around the false violation?

              Frustrating that this is even a problem or that it is attempting to censor in the first place.

              *edit: I do like the gen fill a lot, it works great when it works. I just don't understand why there is so much violations happening, and what it is that I can possibly do to avoid it (legitmately).

               

                P
                pocketd
                Participant
                June 19, 2023

                I think the guidelines are way too strict. I absolutely hate that the tech overlords want to censor and babysit their users. I have a client who is an avid hunter and of course, the word gun is banned. More arbitrary rules that ultimately won't stop people from doing what they want. 

                  MultiMediaArtistPortland
                  MultiMediaArtistPortland
                  Participating Frequently
                  June 19, 2023

                  Adobe Photoshop Beta 24.7

                  Hello World,

                  This evening 6/18/2023 I updated the Adobe Photoshop Beta to V. 24.7. In the image below I was trying to remove the chain as shown in the image below using Generative Fill with no prompt / input and I recieved the shown Community guidelines violation alert. I repeated the same step and received the same results. On the third step I removed the trace and circled the chain again it worked fine. I'm not sure what triggered the Community guidelines violation but though you should know that it seems real finiky. 

                   

                    D Fosse
                    Community Expert
                    D FosseCommunity Expert
                    Community Expert
                    June 19, 2023

                    This is trivial to remove with traditional methods. I don't know why you would use generative fill here.

                      R
                      rb16826567
                      Participating Frequently
                      June 19, 2023

                      same here. 

                      it worked initially but i am getting this error on any image i'm trying to edit this weekend. like taking out a guy far in the background that's already dark and blurry 😞 

                        J
                        Juan30579139g20f
                        Participant
                        June 19, 2023

                        At this point I'm giving up on edititing anything woman related in PS whatsoever. I don't know what were they thinking with this hyper draconian and irrational censoring of a tool made for professional adults.

                          M
                          MontyWales
                          Known Participant
                          June 18, 2023

                          Works fine with most of my MJ images 

                            Show more replies
                            Terms & ConditionsAccessibility statement
                            Using the community Terms of use Privacy Cookie preferences Do not sell or share my personal information ad choicesAdChoices